Pretty good set of quick hits by the guys who study the draft at NFL.com. Although, some of their reasons for one or the other aren't very good reasons to influence the choice.
http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap30...ntz-who-should-rams-take-with-no-1-draft-pick
Goff vs Wentz: Who should the Rams pick?
On Thursday, the
Los Angeles Rams sent shockwaves through the NFL by
jumping from No. 15 in this month's draft all the way up to No. 1. Of course, this move didn't come without a price: The
Rams sent the
Titans two first-round picks, two second-rounders and two third-rounders over the next two drafts (in exchange for No. 1, No. 113 and No. 177 in this month's event). But the trade puts the
Rams in position to (presumably) draft a quarterback to build around as the franchise returns to L.A.
It appears that two signal callers have separated themselves from the pack:
Cal's Jared Goff and
North Dakota State's Carson Wentz. Saturday night at 8 p.m. ET, NFL Network will break down the biggest question heading into the 2016 draft with a special program, "Path to the Draft: Goff or Wentz?" But in the meantime, what do you think? Which of these two QBs should the
Rams select at No. 1 overall?
Carson Wentz has more long-term promise, but Jared Goff is the guy for L.A. in 2016
I like
Carson Wentz over
Jared Goff long term, but Goff is a better fit
right now. And Los Angeles could indeed be a QB away from being a playoff team -- the
Rams have a good defense and a
Pro Bowl RB in
Todd Gurley. Goff has very good pocket presence -- he sees things quickly and has a quick release. But he does not have a top arm.
To be frank, though, I don't think either one of these QBs is an elite prospect.
Wentz is the superior prospect -- in fact, he's better than Blake Bortles was coming out of UCF
They should take
Carson Wentz. He's bigger, more athletic, has a stronger arm and gained experience in an NFL system while at North Dakota State. He's proven to play his best in big moments, and he's done nothing but win his entire athletic career.
Wentz's toughness, competitiveness and football intelligence are off the charts. He's a better player than
Blake Bortles was coming out of Central Florida.
I have Wentz rated slightly higher, but I think Goff is a better fit in Los Angeles
In my rankings -- which will be released on NFL.com on Monday -- I have
Carson Wentz one spot ahead of
Jared Goff. But, if I were the
Rams, I would go with Goff because of the fact the he was raised in California. He would be much more familiar with the difficulty of movement in Los Angeles, mainly traffic and the pace of living. Goff would have an easier time adapting to the high-intensity way of life in the L.A. area. Moving to California would be a culture shock for anybody who has lived their entire life in North Dakota.
Return to L.A. gives Rams more time to develop a QB -- I'd bet on Wentz's upside
If this were still the
St. Louis Rams, I would probably say
Jared Goff because they would need to win more immediately. However, in Los Angeles, the
Rams should have a honeymoon period that allows them to bring
Carson Wentz along with more patience.
At the end of the day, I believe that Wentz has the potential to be a "face of the franchise" quarterback more than Goff.
Goff's experience will allow him to be the Rams' starter on Day 1
The
Rams should take
Jared Goff with the top pick. The Cal quarterback is the more polished and experienced player at the position. Goff enters the NFL with 1,500-plus pass attempts and 37 career college starts (compared to Wentz's 612 attempts and 23 college starts), which makes him better prepared to step into the lineup as a Day 1 starter.
From a physical standpoint, Goff doesn't have the big arm or prototypical dimensions of Wentz, but he displays better footwork and poise in the pocket. He plays with his eyes and feet connected, while exhibiting good poise under duress. Goff's ability to thrive within chaos sets him apart from others in the class and gives him the nod in this debate.
Considering Goff's outstanding touch, timing and anticipation as a passer, the
Rams finally have a chance to field an explosive offense with the potential to attack on the ground or through the air.
Rams made a bold move with win-now intentions, so Goff has to be the pick
You don't blow a hole in two drafts -- as the L.A.
Rams just did in moving up to No. 1 -- to acquire a quarterback who might need a year or two to develop. That's why the choice needs to be
Jared Goff of Cal.
While
Carson Wentz's offense at North Dakota State might have been more NFL-like, it's a mistake to lump Cal's "Bear Raid" offense in with other college spread offenses that translate poorly to the pros. Goff, with an experience edge over Wentz -- and having played against a much higher level of competition in the Pac-12 -- will be more ready to win games right off the bat.
Wentz would seem to be a better fit in the Rams' Todd Gurley-led offense
I'm thinking
Carson Wentz. Unless the
Rams view
Jared Goff as a clearly superior quarterback to Wentz, I would go with the guy who has been
under center more in his career if I were part of the
Rams' brass. Not because Goff can't assimilate himself to pro sets outside of the spread and shotgun, but because the
Rams' best player is tailback
Todd Gurley, who often operates out of a single-back set. The key to the
Rams making big plays downfield this season is having success with play action to Gurley, and that is something -- at least under center -- that Wentz is more equipped to carry out at this stage.
Wentz will fit like a glove into into Jeff Fisher's offense
I have had Jared Goff rated slightly higher than Carson Wentz throughout the run up to the draft. But when it comes to who should the
Rams take with the No. 1 overall pick, I believe they should select Carson Wentz. To me, he would fit nicely with what Los Angeles wants to do on offense given head coach Jeff Fisher's background -- run the ball, hit big plays off of play action, and pair that philosophy with a stout defense already in place. Wentz's background at North Dakota State saw him handling line calls, adjustments and audibles in the run and pass game, and operating a lot of offense from under center, in the pistol and shot gun. His ability to read fronts and control the run game would be valuable.
As an added bonus, his athleticism and comfort running the ball will really come in handy. The possibility of his escaping out the backdoor will help tamp down pressure packages focused solely on stopping
Pro Bowl RB
Todd Gurley, and Wentz's sturdy 6-foot-5, 237-pound frame allows him a great chance to hold up well as a runner.
Finally, with the heavy focus and commitment to running the football, the plan would be for Wentz to be able to throw the ball against easier coverages and in more favorable situations. That would allow him to break into and acclimate to the league quicker, as well as develop without being hit so often early in his career when trying to pass.
This formula worked well for
Ben Roethlisberger and
Russell Wilson as rookies. I think that Carson Wentz would find it agreeable, too.
