Which QB should the Rams draft in the 1st Round next year?

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
IDK might have had his choice of Indiana, LSU, Miami or even close to home in Clemson. All better options than South Carolina under a HC who will be in his last year IMO.
I agree. And it makes me wonder if the kid is afraid of the unknown, the high expectations. Maybe he is a loyal local kid. Or maybe he lacks the mental fortitude.

I think there is a ton more risk staying there. If he can improve and win, it can certaily work out for him. But if not...
 
Sellers returning is a shame for us. Realistically, Simpson now appears to be one of three touted first round QBs who might be in range. But, I have my doubts whether he can replace Stafford even with a year or two in our system. Does he have enough experience? Does he tick enough boxes? Would we be better trading with a team like the Jets for their first round pick next year?

I would not be surprised if we were to try and trade up for him based on reports such as this. He was a 5 star recruit and so his tools might be legit. They gush about his play in the report below. Their assessment is eerily reminiscent of Joe Montana’s skill set which feels like hyperbole

 
Last edited:
I agree. And it makes me wonder if the kid is afraid of the unknown, the high expectations. Maybe he is a loyal local kid. Or maybe he lacks the mental fortitude.

I think there is a ton more risk staying there. If he can improve and win, it can certaily work out for him. But if not...
He lacks "the mental fortitude" because he refused to transfer to a place where it's easier to win? Football and fans have really changed. Wasn't that long ago that people were criticizing players for being "disloyal" and questioning their character. Now, we have players being criticized for being too loyal lol.
 
Sellers returning is a shame for us. Realistically, Simpson now appears to be one of three touted first round QBs who might be in range. But, I have my doubts whether he can replace Stafford even with a year or two in our system. Does he have enough experience? Does he tick enough boxes? Would we be better trading with a team like the Jets for their first round pick next year?

I would not be surprised if we were to try and trade up for him based on reports such as this. He was a 5 star recruit and so his tools might be legit. They gush about his play in the report below. Their assessment is eerily reminiscent of Joe Montana’s skill set which feels like hyperbole

The last couple of games Simpson has not looked good at all. Lets see how he plays against a very good Oklahoma team, who the Tide lost to earlier in the year 23-21.
 
Sellers returning is a shame for us. Realistically, Simpson now appears to be one of three touted first round QBs who might be in range. But, I have my doubts whether he can replace Stafford even with a year or two in our system. Does he have enough experience? Does he tick enough boxes? Would we be better trading with a team like the Jets for their first round pick next year?

I would not be surprised if we were to try and trade up for him based on reports such as this. He was a 5 star recruit and so his tools might be legit. They gush about his play in the report below. Their assessment is eerily reminiscent of Joe Montana’s skill set which feels like hyperbole

I need to take a closer look at Sorsby. I get the feeling that McVay wants a mobile QB. Sorsby is big, athletic, and has a strong arm. Looking at his stats, it appears he's been up and down this year, so I want to see why.
 
Sellers returning is a shame for us. Realistically, Simpson now appears to be one of three touted first round QBs who might be in range. But, I have my doubts whether he can replace Stafford even with a year or two in our system. Does he have enough experience? Does he tick enough boxes? Would we be better trading with a team like the Jets for their first round pick next year?

I would not be surprised if we were to try and trade up for him based on reports such as this. He was a 5 star recruit and so his tools might be legit. They gush about his play in the report below. Their assessment is eerily reminiscent of Joe Montana’s skill set which feels like hyperbole

My initial impression is I'm not sold on Simpson. His deep ball accuracy is really bad when we're talking about potential 1st round prospects and I think that's where you have to start when you're trying to find a potential difference maker at QB.

Mendoza and Dante Moore will be the standard at the QB position in this draft imo.
 
Don't waste a pick on those 2 for sure.
After Mendoza, I wouldn't use either of our 1st rounders on a QB. Especially if MS9 plans on returning for even just one more season.
Load up with talent at either the WO, CB, DL/Edge or OL positions, depending on the BPA at either of those positions.
But then hey, I'm really not a draft expert like everyone else here at ROD, either. :helmet: :cool:
WIN NOW, baby !!!
 
He lacks "the mental fortitude" because he refused to transfer to a place where it's easier to win? Football and fans have really changed. Wasn't that long ago that people were criticizing players for being "disloyal" and questioning their character. Now, we have players being criticized for being too loyal lol.
Easy tiger. We don't know his motivations. Truth is he is all upside. Played like dogshit behind a dogshit line then went back to the same trough for more.

Elite competitor is what I want at QB. Is he that? Not so sure at this point so we will see.
 
:laugh2:

I still kick myself for not going to any of their concerts.... heard they were great. I was too much of a bullet headed metal fan.... though I did go to Prince's Purple Rain tour.
I was also (and still am primarily) a metal head and ALSO went to see Prince on the Purple Rain tour, haha. Good times.
although driving to my bachelor party back in the summer of 1992 in my black IROC with the windows and sunroof open
Say whaaaaa? I had a few IROCs myself back in the day, and I only remember them being available in hard top or T-top. Only sunroof I ever saw on an F Body of that era was an aftermarket job that leaked worse than the T-tops did, haha.
 
Say whaaaaa? I had a few IROCs myself back in the day, and I only remember them being available in hard top or T-top. Only sunroof I ever saw on an F Body of that era was an aftermarket job that leaked worse than the T-tops did, haha.
Yes, T-tops open, that is what I should have communicated.
 
Hopefully he finishes strong. That benefits us either way.
Oklahoma is an excellent test and then Indiana. So, lets see what Simpson has? I still see him as more of a backup option at the next level, but against the likes of Oklahoma and Indiana, I hope he proves me wrong.
 
Yes, T-tops open, that is what I should have communicated.
Funny story used to work with a lady that had a t top trans am back in the day. She thought it would be a great idea to have the custom plate "TplssTA"

Hit on a ton from guys thinking it meant topless tits n ass
 
Easy tiger. We don't know his motivations. Truth is he is all upside. Played like dogshit behind a dogshit line then went back to the same trough for more.

Elite competitor is what I want at QB. Is he that? Not so sure at this point so we will see.
Yeah, I'm going to go out on a limb and say that the QB who refuses to transfer from his struggling team because he wants to turn things around is not less of a "competitor" than the QB who looks for an easier situation to win. ;)
 
We'll see. Right now he looks like a Taysom v2 in the NFL. Has upside but that other shit that's important may be missing.

I'd like to see him behind Stafford. But not nearly as high on him as you are.
 
I agree. And it makes me wonder if the kid is afraid of the unknown, the high expectations. Maybe he is a loyal local kid. Or maybe he lacks the mental fortitude.

I think there is a ton more risk staying there. If he can improve and win, it can certaily work out for him. But if not...
If someone is determined to be successful despite more risk, doesn't that mean they have more mental fortitude, not less?

There's no way for us to know all of the stuff that goes into the equation for these decisions.
 
We'll see. Right now he looks like a Taysom v2 in the NFL. Has upside but that other shit that's important may be missing.

I'd like to see him behind Stafford. But not nearly as high on him as you are.
It's fair to doubt him as a passer. He needs work there. My objection is to questioning his intangibles because he refuses to transfer. (And let's be honest, Taysom Hill doesn't lack competitiveness.)
 
There's no way for us to know all of the stuff that goes into the equation for these decisions.
Precisely my point.

It's fair to doubt him as a passer. He needs work there. My objection is to questioning his intangibles because he refuses to transfer. (And let's be honest, Taysom Hill doesn't lack competitiveness.)
My comment was in part because you were so quick to act like the kid is sticking around due to only good reasons. Trying to keep it real. There could be much more in play in that young head of his, and we don't know what his motivation is.

Many young kids nowadays, in fact, are afraid of the unknown and will hang around with some bullshit in spite of the fact it's better for them to venture into that unknown. You can disregard it all you want. Knock yourself out. But none of us know what's in his head.

I'd like to see him succeed next year. So on top of all that the further point was that if he doesn't get good protections and sucks ass again in 2026 it's gonna kill his draft value. Now he may be too young to realize all that. But if he has an agent I would hope his counsel was to seek out a better program that comes with weapons and protections.