Which QB should the Rams draft in the 1st Round next year?

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Difference in slotting is Goff is tall enough to see over his center's shoulders, and played more than one season in college.

Those things almost certainly will drop him. If McVay takes him anywhere I'll get behind it of course, because I trust his take on the QBs. But I think highest I'd consider him to be a logical pick would be late first, and that's only because you can argue that 5th year option makes the pick worthwhile.

I suspect he's a round 3 grade dude. Would be round 2 if he had more game tape and you could comp him to Brees, but as things stand that sample size is a problem for me.
The comparison with Goff was strictly regarding arm strength
If he truly is 6'2 he'll be a 1st rounder
Now that Trinidad has entered the chat, it will be interesting to see how things change
Could end up with 4 QB in the 1st round
 
The comparison with Goff was strictly regarding arm strength
If he truly is 6'2 he'll be a 1st rounder
Now that Trinidad has entered the chat, it will be interesting to see how things change
Could end up with 4 QB in the 1st round
Yes I am aware you nerds were comparing dicks with arm strength. :laugh2:

Agreed that his height really matters here. That alone would not be such an issue if the sample size was bigger, but it's not and the combination of shit is what hurts him.

All that aside though Simpson does happen to be a QB that fits very much what McVay wants at the position. So I'd imagine that McVay and his staff will nuke the everliving fuck out of his film and character, maybe even count the corn in his stools.

Also I am willing to admit maybe under McVay a QB like Simpson could flourish. I agree with Jrry that McVay is very flexible. Particularly with the guys who at least are capable of stretching the field, which he is. What I wonder about is where they would see him having value. Senior Bowl week is gonna be interesting.
 
I just have to disagree about Simpson being on par with Goff's. Goff has a fantastic arm, much better than Simpson's, and his anticipation and accuracy is at least the same, if not better. The issue with Goff is that under pressure, there's no escapability, and he makes poor decisions. Simpson does not have the arm talent Goff has. I don't think he'll ever have the capability of executing everything our offense needs to do.

He's better at creating than Goff and very comfortable in the pocket and stepping up (rather than retreating), which is the gold standard in the NFL, but not something you see much from college QBs. He also plays under centre, unlike Chambliss and Mendoza, and so we know he is comfortable and capable of not only playing under centre but then going through his reads having had his back to the play ( again, that is rare in College). That said, he's QB3, as of now, and it will likely stay that way unless Moore doesn't declare for the draft (which would be a huge mistake by him IMO)

I don't agree that he will last until the 2nd round for the following reason: It seems unlikely that he would last past the Steelers. That's why, IMO, if we want him, we will need to use our first pick. If we trade back, we would need to be sure the Steelers could not jump us. So, if we [and other teams] fall in love with him during interviews [the interviews often get leaked and reported], we probably cannot trade back and may even have to trade up.

Rather, could we turn either of our round 1 picks into an additional 1st round pick next year, plus a lower pick(s) in this draft? If so (and we are not wowed by Ty's interview), there must be a reasonable chance we trade (potentially to a team that wants to draft him) and wait a year for our future QB.
 
As long as McVay is coach I don't see him drafting a rookie to replace Stafford. His demands requires another veteran to take over, who would be? having said that, may be that's when he steps down.
He came to the Rams when Goff was practically a rookie.
I do not get why so many fans try and say McVay needs a vet or he will retire. Ludicrus .
He seen a opportunity to get Stafford.................. and took it. He seen it as a upgrade, and it was.
Thats all that happened.
I am positive of one thing, McVay needs his starting QB to be high IQ. Goff was not stupid, but he is not whip smart either. We all seen the sunset deal. Then he openly say he would pipe her. Not that bright.
 
* Rams do not value iOL: draft Avila with top pick (36).
* Rams do not value iLB: extend Landman to multi year extension
* Rams do not value Safety: extend Lake to multi year extension

Just some of the prior myths to this current Rams McSnead organization. Maybe the myths had some validity to it at times, but this FO is smart enough to self scout, evolve and change as needed.
 
That's exactly what we have already done to no success. Except for Bennet, who stuck around. But he's no#1 qb.
 
I am positive of one thing, McVay needs his starting QB to be high IQ. Goff was not stupid, but he is not whip smart either.
I suspect this is very accurate. Goff may be smarter than he appears to be, but IQ is definitely a huge factor with McVay and dudes who are on the dull side are going to get worn down by his expectations.

Also dedication to the QB craft I think is really important with McVay. It is of course a primary predictor of success with every QB at this level. But to play for McVay requires the type of QB who is excited about the game, talking it, planning it, studying it, etc. Which is another thing we can't really evaluate all that accurately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ram Ts and Ramstien
So which QB coming out of college this year would best fit in McVay's system?
Think we need to wait and see who declares to answer that.

Two personal favorites of those I've looked at are Mateer and Leavitt, though neither may declare and Mateer I keep hearing will return, but he reminds me of a less stupid Mayfield. Leavitt is really talented to my eye at least and in fact has hit the portal so is probably a 2027 draft QB.

Like most here I was really high on Simpson early this season, he felt like a dude who got overlooked. Now I'm thinking maybe there was a reason he sat on that bench. Also QBs with short sample size don't usually do well in the NFL, though the Rams seem to offer a redshirt and time to learn and grow.

There's a lot of QBs on the shorter end it feels like. So weigh ins and practices (Senior Bowl, combine etc) should be illuminating.
 
The comparison with Goff was strictly regarding arm strength
If he truly is 6'2 he'll be a 1st rounder
Now that Trinidad has entered the chat, it will be interesting to see how things change
Could end up with 4 QB in the 1st round
We'll have to wait and see what Chambliss does. But if he does declare, I'll take a long look at him. Despite his uneven performance against Miami, I've been impressed with him this year. I don't like Lane Kiffin's system for NFL development purposes, but Chambliss would have an opportunity to sit and learn here.
 
We'll have to wait and see what Chambliss does. But if he does declare, I'll take a long look at him. Despite his uneven performance against Miami, I've been impressed with him this year. I don't like Lane Kiffin's system for NFL development purposes, but Chambliss would have an opportunity to sit and learn here.
Chambliss appeal was denied so he’s gonna be in the draft for sure