Dude, did you go watch him again? Are you saying he wasn't mobile? Is this just a harrass RamzFanz reply or are you going to assess his actual play vs the assumptions?
I have already evaluated Davis many times in other threads and found him wanting. Now I'm trying to talk about Hill.
Can I talk about Hill without being accused of alternative motives or am I upsetting the bandwagon again?
I'm saying when he goes "mobile" he pulls muscles cuz he isn't in nearly as good shape as Davis, his physique reminds me of a guy who spent the off season expecting to be a backup, I've been every age either of these guys have been and was into athletics and trained diligently . Age takes a toll ,I'll give you that Hill has experience Davis has youth, Hill has a better arm and is more accurate, Davis has fire and the hunger of a man who wants a career where Hill has accepted long ago a fate of being a backup.
Where was Davis when Fisher found him? studying for the game , was Hill there with him? No , he had to call Fisher back.
I said Hill won't be here next year and I firmly believe that, Davis may be if he still wants to. I think Davis will be back in there sooner than later but hesitate to say why because once you say things you root for them to happen.
I have made my assessment of the two and find it to be a push, and Hill has ONLY lost the one half he has played . For me the experience we are giving Davis now can be an asset for the future , and I don't think our record would or will be any better with Hill so my position is to stick with the kid let him grow BECAUSE I don't think the change is going to salvage the season , Hill may win a game Davis won't and vice versa.
I hope we rip off 7 straight wins Hill wins comeback player of the year we beat the Cardinals in the NFC Championship Game beat the Broncos for a second time in the Super Bowl and Pizza Hut buys out Papa Johns and hires Hill to do commercials.
As far as AM I harassing you ? No, I'm responding , let me ask you this, don't you think if you had been Hill and Fisher jerked the rug out from under you , you might hold some animosity ? I think you might , he may even be thinking "oh yeah NOW you want me in there ,I'm supposed to save your season NOW? " further 'I had the shot at having my own team ,I get hurt and am willing to keep playing and you put this kid in there and he does OK and then you give him my job even though you promised you wouldn't" . No he won't say those things that would be highly impolitic, but I'll bet it's crossed his mind .
Fish hates QB controversy, but man has he proven to be adept at creating one