Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Yes, absolutely.

There is both the cumulative impact that can lead to injuries on multiple levels. And there’s also the frequency and exposure aspect. When you’re spamming those underneath place to him, he’s getting hit more often and by more players and by bigger players because he’s closer to the line.

You’re exposing him to running back usage. And what’s the lifespan of running backs in the NFL these days?
I'm not sure about the science regarding your cumulative impact claim, so no debate from me for or against your claim.

I get the argument against spamming the underneath passes. The issue is, he got injured on a run and McVay has always liberally used him as a RB, even with better roster construction. It's a tenuous connection at best for me.

More importantly, I think McVay and Stafford have allowed the crutch of overusing their top weapons for McVay's entire tenure. When the top weapons are missing, the offense continues to score, and typically gets more efficient, proving that it's not a lack of resources or a roster construction issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PhillyRam
I'm not sure about the science regarding your cumulative impact claim, so no debate from me for or against your claim.

I get the argument against spamming the underneath passes. The issue is, he got injured on a run and McVay has always liberally used him as a RB, even with better roster construction. It's a tenuous connection at best for me.

More importantly, I think McVay and Stafford have allowed the crutch of overusing their top weapons for McVay's entire tenure. When the top weapons are missing, the offense continues to score, and typically gets more efficient, proving that it's not a lack of resources or a roster construction issue.

I don’t think we’re disagreeing.

I’m not saying “never target Puka on screens or underneath or run him”..

I’m saying using him that way and that much really made injury inevitable.

Think about things like fatigue, making it harder to avoid being hit, things like that. And again, it’s cumulative. That’s why I brought up the running back comp.
 
Yeah, I’m not giving up on the season.
But, the path narrowed.
Possibly the biggest issue right now, outside of the injuries. is special teams.

The formula for winning when your offense isn’t great is an outstanding defense and excellent special teams.
Even with Puka, the Rams can't start any game until the last 5 minutes of the 1st half. That all by itself will knock them out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pupped and DzRams
I guess now we know the real reason why they changed course and put Puka on IR.

Now it is even more imperative to get Ferg and Adams back healthy playing. Unfortunately, the news for both of them is not encouraging (yet). So it may come down to a new run dominant scheme. Either way, it’s a daunting task with such a brutal schedule remaining.
 
I don’t think we’re disagreeing.

I’m not saying “never target Puka on screens or underneath or run him”..

I’m saying using him that way and that much really made injury inevitable.

Think about things like fatigue, making it harder to avoid being hit, things like that. And again, it’s cumulative. That’s why I brought up the running back comp.
I definitely think it's cumulative over the course of a career. But I'm skeptical of a cumulative effect after two weeks of different usage.

If the cumulative susceptibility to injury happened that quickly, RBs should be injured at a much higher rate than WRs. Studies show that they're rate of injury is a bit higher but not significantly higher. Think about it: a RB has 15-25 touches per game behind the LOS versus a WR who may have 5-7.
 
Even with Puka, the Rams can't start any game until the last 5 minutes of the 1st half. That all by itself will knock them out.
You are right. We have not yet seen the offense being worse without Puka. It will probably happen but IMO it's too early to conclude that the offense will be bad.
 
I definitely think it's cumulative over the course of a career. But I'm skeptical of a cumulative effect after two weeks of different usage.

If the cumulative susceptibility to injury happened that quickly, RBs should be injured at a much higher rate than WRs. Studies show that they're rate of injury is a bit higher but not significantly higher. Think about it: a RB has 15-25 touches per game behind the LOS versus a WR who may have 5-7.
Well.. Puka’s usage was already on the very very high level.. so, we’re talking about amplification that.
 
  • Cheers
Reactions: DzRams
You are right. We have not yet seen the offense being worse without Puka. It will probably happen but IMO it's too early to conclude that the offense will be bad.
Without Puka

Week 2 (NYG)
Matthew went for 327 and 4 TDs
The RBs ran for 163 yds on 28 combined carries.

Week 3 (DEN)
Stafford 390 yards passing
RBs 116 yds on the ground

Puka is great but put me in the camp that still thinks we can move the ball.
 
Puka plays a physical style thats going to create contact. Sure limitting his touches may help. But really it could happen the first time he touches the ball.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Psycho_X
Every time a player touches the ball there is a chance of injury. So increase touches, increases chances. He was already playing injured. A groin not at 100% will slow reaction time and as you get tired it would increase that affect. On top of that he had turf toe. Which also makes movement to avoid contact more difficult. So yeah, there is a cumulative effect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Ray
Without Puka

Week 2 (NYG)
Matthew went for 327 and 4 TDs
The RBs ran for 163 yds on 28 combined carries.

Week 3 (DEN)
Stafford 390 yards passing
RBs 116 yds on the ground

Puka is great but put me in the camp that still thinks we can move the ball.
The way McVay currently utilizes Nacua actually hinders the offense, IMO.
 
  • High Five
Reactions: DzRams
Obviously injuries happen - they could even happen celebrating a big play (cough)

but don't we all agree that players are more at least somewhat more likely to get injured on plays where they are getting tackled than on plays where they are not?

Puka is the perfect storm - he plays like a wildman anyway - and he tends to touch the ball 15 times a game.
 
With Puka missing the remainder of the season, who could we have traded for that would make up for his absence? Allen? Downs?

I think they should pursue Aiyuk. I don't see any of the trade options as being players that would have moved the needle.
I think there is a non-zero chance Aiyuk is on our practice squad by Thanksgiving waiting to clear waivers. If he's in decent shape we could sign him to a one year prove it deal and get him up to speed for the SF game in week 14.

The NFL scriptwriters would love that scenario.

We'd probably lose, but the possible niner fanbase meltdown of losing the top seed in a home game against the Rams (with Aiyuk playing for vengeance) is more temptation than I can turn down. Huge schadenboner potential.
 
Well, this sucks donkey balls.

But ... we will rally around CJ Daniels ... and Konata Mumfield ... and Tutu Atwell ... and Xavier Smith ... and Max Klare ... and we will play good football.

Let's hope. Those guys need to grow up in a hurry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RamFanWA
Its gonna be the Davante Adams, RB twins, and TE show down the stretch run. I expect a ton of 13 with Ferguson taking the top off every now and then.