Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
How does it take weeks to determine surgery is the right course of action? I mean a MRI and a couple opinions don’t take weeks

Could have been determined and we just don’t know. MCLs (and ACLs) require swelling to go down prior to surgery. Just cause we didn’t hear about it doesn’t mean this wasn’t the case
 
I think it came down to lack of draft capital, and the thought that they are not in a great spot at this point anyway for this year in terms of having a great shot to win it due to injuries & current record along with the strength of the NFC.

Then the thought that maybe there was not a trade target out there that they felt could improve their chances a great deal, nor was a fit not just in play style, but contract and how he would fit the future.

In-other-words, a 1 yr rental was not worth giving up draft capital for. Nor would be a high priced vet who would cost even more in dradt capital, who might be cooked or might not be a personality fit.

I mean you really think rentals like Keenan Allen or Josh Downs moves the needle to the point where they can go and win 3 road playoff games against this conference this year?

I would chalk this year up to that it just wasn't their year. Too many Injuries, tough conference, rough schedule down the stretch, and they screwed up that Australia trip, along with the slow start to start the year, with shitty special teams again. So I am not absolving them. They screwed up early and are in a hole that they must realize they can't dig out of, especially with the injuries they now have.
Disagree, totally screwed the pooch on this one
 
  • Like
Reactions: dieterbrock
Well, I stated it multiple times… The Rams have increased the underneath and screen passes to him. That exposes him to way more hits.
It’s a usage decision.
While he was not the most refined outside receiver, when he came into the league, he absolutely thrives in that role now.
I think it’s obvious the Rams knew that this was a problem, but didn’t see a way out this season.
Max Klare and Ferguson are both players who will take a tremendous amount of that work off of Puka’s shoulders.
I still think that they messed up in the draft. by not targeting a receiver much higher, but that’s all in the rearview mirror at this point.
I can agree with the play calling for him, but that's not roster construction.
 
I could see a shorter term deal, for big money, but shorter term. Protects the Rams and it gets Puka to FA again while he is still near his prime. So could be a win win contract. Question would be would his team want a 2nd shot at FA in 2 or 3 yrs?
This is what I'm thinking. I say we exhaust every single available avenue in keeping Puka. TOO good to cast aside. Take this to all available limits including tagging of course. If someone makes a trade offer that's too good to be true, we can consider that. Still want Puka long term.
 
Who should they have traded for and what do you give up?
Who cares, nothing was done and that's an issue with a big injury like that. Sorry but I'm not interested in debating something I believe they did which was fumbling the bag on this one, just what I believe.
 
That’s not the question.
He has run the same basic offense for 10 yrs now. If anything they rely more on the ground game now which should help the WRs target load. Not as pass happy as in the past.

They actually run fewer jet sweeps than they did in his early years. And they utilize the TEs more than ever in the passing game.

Like I said, even when Adams is healthy, Stafford locks onto Nacua the same way he locked onto Kupp. Was the roster construction poor then, when Kupp kept getting hurt?
 
Angry Work GIF


Angry He Man GIF
 
He has run the same basic offense for 10 yrs now. If anything they rely more on the ground game now which should help the WRs target load. Not as pass happy as in the past.

They actually run fewer jet sweeps than they did in his early years. And they utilize the TEs more than ever in the passing game.

Like I said, even when Adams is healthy, Stafford locks onto Nacua the same way he locked onto Kupp. Was the roster construction poor then, when Kupp kept getting hurt?
Yeah.

Just say you don’t wanna answer the question.
 
Well, I stated it multiple times… The Rams have increased the underneath and screen passes to him. That exposes him to way more hits.
It’s a usage decision.
I agree that they increased the underneath and screen passes which expose him to more hits.

Are you saying that the accumulation of hits made him more susceptible to injury? That if it wasn't for that increased usage, his body would have been in better condition to not get injured on a running play?

It's not super clear what you're saying.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RamBall
Disagree, totally screwed the pooch on this one
With Puka missing the remainder of the season, who could we have traded for that would make up for his absence? Allen? Downs?

I think they should pursue Aiyuk. I don't see any of the trade options as being players that would have moved the needle.
 
I agree that they increased the underneath and screen passes which expose him to more hits.

Are you saying that the accumulation of hits made him more susceptible to injury? That if it wasn't for that increased usage, his body would have been in better condition to not get injured on a running play?

It's not super clear what you're saying.
Yes, absolutely.

There is both the cumulative impact that can lead to injuries on multiple levels. And there’s also the frequency and exposure aspect. When you’re spamming those underneath passes to him, he’s getting hit more often and by more players and by bigger players because he’s closer to the line.

You’re exposing him to running back usage. And what’s the lifespan of running backs in the NFL these days?
 
Last edited:
With Puka missing the remainder of the season, who could we have traded for that would make up for his absence? Allen? Downs?

I think they should pursue Aiyuk. I don't see any of the trade options as being players that would have moved the needle.
They should absolutely kick the tires.
But he hasn’t played in a long time, and is a head case.

I think the best path to success for them is getting Adams and Ferguson back and running a ton of 13 personnel.
 
This sucks. On a more positive note, I am not as down as many of you on the receiving options we still have. All the extra practice time Stafford will have with the other receivers will make a difference. I don't think the offense will have to compensate for a weakness. They will just have to use what they have. Call different plays. Play to different strengths. Also 13p can still win games. Plus the D is better than it has been. This is not SB ending. The were going to be without Puka at least the next 3 games anyway. Go Rams.
 
This sucks. On a more positive note, I am not as down as many of you on the receiving options we still have. All the extra practice time Stafford will have with the other receivers will make a difference. I don't think the offense will have to compensate for a weakness. They will just have to use what they have. Play to different strengths. Also 13p can still win games. Plus the D is better than it has been. This is not SB ending. The were going to be without Puka at least the next 3 games anyway. Go Rams.
Yeah, I’m not giving up on the season.
But, the path narrowed.
Possibly the biggest issue right now, outside of the injuries. is special teams.

The formula for winning when your offense isn’t great is an outstanding defense and excellent special teams.