Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
We are definitely Franchise Tagging him. He still very well may have a long career with us. I tell you this, I'm not accepting anything less than a 1st Rounder for him.
If non elite Sauce Gardiner garners 2 1st round picks (which may I remind may tender the 1st overall pick this year), Puka deserves at least that.
 
If non elite Sauce Gardiner garners 2 1st round picks (which may I remind may tender the 1st overall pick this year), Puka deserves at least that.
I'm pretty sure it doesn't work that way. I would love to get two 1sts for Puka but little chance of that happening.
 
If it wasn't that last run he got injured on, it would have been something else eventually. He's incapable of staying healthy. Still sucks though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RamBall
Not much more to say that hasn't been said. The offense was too reliant on Puka. Injuries where bount to happen with his physical style.

McVay and the team have to move forward. Get ready for the Packers game.
 
Complete epic fuckin failure to bring in help......wow, this is not good
I think it came down to lack of draft capital, and the thought that they are not in a great spot at this point anyway for this year in terms of having a great shot to win it due to injuries & current record along with the strength of the NFC.

Then the thought that maybe there was not a trade target out there that they felt could improve their chances a great deal, nor was a fit not just in play style, but contract and how he would fit the future.

In-other-words, a 1 yr rental was not worth giving up draft capital for. Nor would be a high priced vet who would cost even more in dradt capital, who might be cooked or might not be a personality fit.

I mean you really think rentals like Keenan Allen or Josh Downs moves the needle to the point where they can go and win 3 road playoff games against this conference this year?

I would chalk this year up to that it just wasn't their year. Too many Injuries, tough conference, rough schedule down the stretch, and they screwed up that Australia trip, along with the slow start to start the year, with shitty special teams again. So I am not absolving them. They screwed up early and are in a hole that they must realize they can't dig out of, especially with the injuries they now have.
 
Weird season with constant delays to surgeries that could have got players back quicker. Don't get it... if these couple weeks is the difference to him being back for playoffs or not that's a serious misstep. Bleh.
 
How does it take weeks to determine surgery is the right course of action? I mean a MRI and a couple opinions don’t take weeks
Swelling goes down, get a better look, 2nd opinion. Maybe his team decided it would be better to get the surgery for his future. Maybe they went out and got other opinions.
 
I think it came down to lack of draft capital, and the thought that they are not in a great spot at this point anyway for this year in terms of having a great shot to win it due to injuries & current record along with the strength of the NFC.

Then the thought that maybe there was not a trade target out there that they felt could improve their chances a great deal, nor was a fit not just in play style, but contract and how he would fit the future.

In-other-words, a 1 yr rental was not worth giving up draft capital for. Nor would be a high priced vet who would cost even more in dradt capital, who might be cooked or might not be a personality fit.

I mean you really think rentals like Keenan Allen or Josh Downs moves the needle to the point where they can go and win 3 road playoff games against this conference this year?

I would chalk this year up to that it just wasn't their year. Too many Injuries, tough conference, rough schedule down the stretch, and they screwed up that Australia trip, along with the slow start to start the year, with shitty special teams again. So I am not absolving them. They screwed up early and are in a hole that they must realize they can't dig out of, especially with the injuries they now have.
Amazing cope.
Obvious roster construction issue lead to this.

That being said.. season ain’t over.

McVay backed into a corner.. or, better yet.. forced to create solutions rather than pursue his “ideal”… is, imo.. the best version of McVay.
 
Amazing cope.
Obvious roster construction issue lead to this.

That being said.. season ain’t over.

McVay backed into a corner.. or, better yet.. forced to create solutions rather than pursue his “ideal”… is, imo.. the best version of McVay.
Well, I think Puka's play mentality lead to this. His play style can lead to this injury whether he gets 12 targets a game or 5 targets. It takes one play. Plus, Stafford doesn't even throw to Devante when he and Puka are playing together.

So not sure how Puka's play style or target number changes much even if the Rams drafted a WR in rd 1 or 2 this year. And not sure how roster construction lead to all of the other injuries. Explain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RamBall and DzRams
Seeing that it was Puka's camps decision to have surgery. I'm cool with that. Still think we can reach a nice 3 or 4 year deal in the offseason that works for everyone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RamBall
Amazing cope.
Obvious roster construction issue lead to this.

That being said.. season ain’t over.

McVay backed into a corner.. or, better yet.. forced to create solutions rather than pursue his “ideal”… is, imo.. the best version of McVay.
Agree. I don't think Nacua was going to be the factor that determines whether or not we win a Super Bowl this year.
 
Well, I think Puka's play mentality lead to this. His play style can lead to this injury whether he gets 12 targets a game or 5 targets. It takes one play. Plus, Stafford doesn't even throw to Devante when he and Puka are playing together.

So not sure how Puka's play style or target number changes much even if the Rams drafted a WR in rd 1 or 2 this year. And not sure how roster construction lead to all of the other injuries. Explain.
Well, I stated it multiple times… The Rams have increased the underneath and screen passes to him. That exposes him to way more hits.
It’s a usage decision.
While he was not the most refined outside receiver, when he came into the league, he absolutely thrives in that role now.
I think it’s obvious the Rams knew that this was a problem, but didn’t see a way out this season.
Max Klare and Ferguson are both players who will take a tremendous amount of that work off of Puka’s shoulders.
I still think that they messed up in the draft. by not targeting a receiver much higher, but that’s all in the rearview mirror at this point.
 
Seeing that it was Puka's camps decision to have surgery. I'm cool with that. Still think we can reach a nice 3 or 4 year deal in the offseason that works for everyone.
I could see a shorter term deal, for big money, but shorter term. Protects the Rams and it gets Puka to FA again while he is still near his prime. So could be a win win contract. Question would be would his team want a 2nd shot at FA in 2 or 3 yrs?