I was watching a show the other day and it said Allen Robinson was ranked 144 out of 145 WR in separation on his routes run. I think he is washed.
Or is it just taking AR longer to adapt to playing in this offense than we had hoped?
Sure, he's still a reciever and has to get open and catch the ball like every other.... but McVays offense demands so much more from it's starting WRs that it probably wouldn't be unfair to compare it to learning an entirely different position.
Learning a new play calling lingo can take some time before it sinks in but learning a new playbook and new teammates, coaches, facilities, culture - all that would make any head spin. Add the weight of SB expectations to his shoulders.... that's a lot to digest mentally before he can stop thinking and just play fast with confidence.
Nothing will make a healthy player appear slower and sloppier than playing with uncertainty...
I remember a lot of people citing all sorts of shit to convince us that OBJ was washed-up in CLE and that the Rams were crazy for signing him and they were just adding big names for the star power to attract attention in LA, he would be a distraction and is a bad teammate.... it was all a bunch of puffed up bullshit.
Did OBJ get faster or become a better athlete by playing in horns? Did his hand-eye coordination improve in the California weather?
AR might become a huge addition for us or he might be as disappointing as Drew Bennett was for us - I have no idea. But I do think evaluating him after a dozen or so games makes a lot more sense than declaring him washed up after a dozen or so targets...