Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
When Puka was out only DA was catching passes. Same when Puka was in. Seattle has the same issue with any WR not JSN. Offense is a joke until they get the ball to him. Mahomes with Hill was a different QB. The list goes on.

Given, its a team sport and Oline and QB are massive to the equation.

I think especially in Puka's case we have seen at times he is the Rams only offense in crunch time.

Can you eventually find a Julian Edelman that can catch 10 catches a game in crunch time? Yes, but not sure those guys grow on trees.


Maybe a rookie like CJ Daniels emerges in the next 7+ games. But relying on the others or old man DA going forward does not seem wise.

Rams best option to me seems to be to pay Puka his 160M. Stretch it out so you can resign key players. Turner and Young are more easily replaceable. Turner wasnt really missed to be honest and Young can disappear for long stretches. I think you sign Avila or Dotson and let the other walk and roll with one of your backups such as Deidich or Limmer. We have another season or two to make a run with this defense and Stafford/Puka and the RB's.
Tyreek Hill? KC smartly dealt him instead of overpaying him and won two Championships. Yes. Mahomes is a different QB, but it's my belief that his ability to keep drives alive with his legs is his best strength. (As much as I hate it and cringe watching, I'm impressed and can appreciate Brock Purdy doing some of the same things). Hopefully, Simpson, while probably not at the same level physically as Mahomes, can enjoy of the same success using his legs with the Rams.

Anyway an offense can be a joke minus a Puka or JSN if it is designed/schemed for that particular player to get the ball and if the QB has tunnel vision and repeatedly targets said WR without developing as much chemistry with other targets (Crucial if he can't do anything with his legs).

As great as Puka is, I've seen many plays where other players are open or breaking open and the ball simply doesn't come their way.

Just like D'Marco Farr stated on a Between the Horns episode, Konata Mumpfield can separate, but they just don't throw him the ball.
 
Last edited:
As much as I hate it and cringe watching, I'm impressed and can appreciate Brock Purdy doing some of the same things). Hopefully, Simpson, while probably not at the same level physically as Mahomes, can enjoy of the same success using his legs with the Rams.
I bet there's a part of McVay seeing all the things his buddy (Shanny) can do with a mobile, via rollouts and picking up 1st downs scrambling that he's salivating to get the chance at via Simpson.

A part. I said a part. He still loves Staff as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Flatlyner

I feel Puka has put his house in order. His actions as a 24 year-old are maturing as he heads towards 26. My biggest concern is his usage and style of play lends itself to injury, and that won’t get better as he gets older. We also saw what happened to Cooper Kupp after his Generational 2021 season. I would think it’s in the Rams and Nacua’s best interest that they don’t use him as a 12 target/2 run weapon anymore. Which means he won’t have the stats to be a top 3WR anymore and that should be factored into his next contract. But we all know he can be the best weapon in the NFL when needed in the Rams should want him for that.
 
Also, Puka would be a much needed comfort zone for a rookie QB. I hope the heck he continues to wear the horns.
 
I would love for Puka to be a Ram......this year, next year, 2028. I felt the same about Kupp. But if Puka is not, so be it. We won before Puka arrived and we'll win when he's gone. There are always great receivers coming into the NFL every year. Les has found them in the 3rd and the 5th round for god sakes. He'll find another. If he leaves in free agency we'll surely get the highest 3rd round comp (#97). If we tag him and somebody gives up two 1st round picks, all the better. Would love to keep him but it's far from the end of the world if we don't. #Nameonthefront!!!
 
I watched the Terrell Owens documentary recently. TO, who was infamous for being a problematic teammate, worked his ass off to rehab to get back for the Super Bowl after suffering a very severe ankle injury. He refused the surgery to help his team win the Super Bowl. His team came up just short in the Super Bowl, but TO played well at less than 100%.

What's my point? Puka could have rehabbed it, put off the surgery, and waited to see if we were in position to make a playoff run. If we were, he could have come back and tried to help us win a Super Bowl. So if Puka really is the person who made the call to get the surgery, yeah, that's shitty of him. It would confirm my instinct that we should tag him this offseason rather than making a long-term commitment to him.

TO was set for life.

Puka made a business decision
 
I'm sure they could structure his contract a certain way to pay him and maximize their chances of keeping some of our other FAs but they really seem to have dropped the ball there. Maybe things will change closer to the free agency deadline but you should pay superstars like Puka. Its a damn shame that it seems like Puka's having to decide to protect himself because the Rams don't want to financially commit to someone that has been a stud with them the whole time. Should have already paid the man.
It sounds good, but do we even know what Puka is asking for? Maybe he isn't receptive to some of the possible stipulations the Rams might want to use to protect themselves. Plus we know he plays hard but we also know that he puts his foot in his mouth. Who knows what he says to the rams. I am only pointing out that we have a lot of opinions about a lot of stuff we don't know.

One thing is for sure, Puka can't point to other players as examples of the Rams extending them and not him. I don't know what the Rams plan is, but it has me worried, the lack of extensions to any of our free agents to be.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: El Chapo Jr
Ummmm... I watched the guy play. He wasn't in Kupp and Puka's league in terms of YAC. His good YAC numbers in those years were largely scheme. Using Pro Football Reference's broken tackle numbers, Woods had a TOTAL of 7 broken tackles between 2018 and 2021 (i.e., his entire Rams career, aside from 2017 - PFR doesn't have the numbers for 2017). Cooper Kupp broke 12 tackles in 2020 alone. Puka broke 11 tackles in 2025 alone.

So don't try to revise history. I remember those years well.
Lol.. you're trying to redefine the YAC statistic now?

Like the guy in the Mississippi commercial and Mayor Clay Davis would say... Sheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeiiiit.

They got YAC in different ways.. and Robert Woods was an excellent YAC guy.. he was faster than Kupp and more elusive while Kupp, yes, broke more tackles.

You're making a distinction without a difference.

Here's Woods on one of McVay's favorite types of plays for Puka..


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJ1TGR0aMLg
 
I would love for Puka to be a Ram...... If he leaves in free agency we'll surely get the highest 3rd round comp (#97). If we tag him and somebody gives up two 1st round picks, all the better.
I think expectations are too high on a tag and trade for Puka. Two first round picks for a guy coming off knee surgery and a league suspension - who requires a huge extension. Idk man. Either way, it’ll be an interesting story for the Rams off-season (yet again).
 
The best comp to the Puka contract situation, to me, may be Deebo.

The Rams don't run Puka the way the 9ers used Deebo.. but the spamming of the WR screens and underneath stuff is the best comparison, usage wise, I can think of. I was cringing at the hits Puka was taking this year.

I hate the idea of tagging him.. it just takes away some important flexibility you have in structuring contracts, but I can see, especially coming off of serious surgery, that it might be the way.
 
Hoping that the new receiving corps, and seeing who can do what and what works with MS, will mean, if Puka stays, he will get fewer targets and take fewer hits.

Loved Devante's comments above.
 

Yeah that was a reassuring statement from one of the NFLs most experienced players.

And this is why today we don't have to be concerned about attracting talent.

And this starts with upper management. In the past 10 years the Rams has given much confidence in the high level quality of an organization we as fans have not seen since Georgia killed her husband. (Jury still out).
 
Lol.. you're trying to redefine the YAC statistic now?
L-O-L. I don't box-score scout players I watched play for years on this team. You want to base your opinion on a stat (that doesn't even support your argument). I base my opinion on what I saw. Woods produced well in terms of YAC here because of the role he played. We generally had him running the intermediate in-cutting routes. He was getting hit in stride with a lot of room to run. Rarely was Woods catching it, breaking tackles, and creating yardage after catch when there wasn't space. The YAC yards were schemed up for him. It's why his YAC averages completely fell off when he left the Rams. Cooper Kupp, despite also being on the decline, averaged over 6 yards after catch per reception last year in Seattle.

Memphis proposed taking Woods out of the role he thrived in and putting him in the Kupp and Puka role. That would have required Woods to break more tackles, something he wasn't good at it. As I said to Memphis, Woods would have been very productive in that role because of his athleticism and route running, but he wouldn't have been as good as Puka or Kupp because he did not have their YAC ability.
Like the guy in the Mississippi commercial and Mayor Clay Davis would say... Sheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeiiiit.

They got YAC in different ways.. and Robert Woods was an excellent YAC guy.. he was faster than Kupp and more elusive while Kupp, yes, broke more tackles.

You're making a distinction without a difference.

Here's Woods on one of McVay's favorite types of plays for Puka..



View:
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJ1TGR0aMLg

They got YAC in different ways because they played different roles. Woods's role came with more space. Woods was not an excellent YAC guy. He was pretty good at it. If he had space, he could pick up yards after catch, but he usually wasn't breaking through or eluding multiple tacklers like Kupp and Puka can. Even on the play you showed, we blocked it up perfectly, caught NYG off guard, and Woods merely had to find a seam and outrun pursuit. X. Smith did something similar against Arizona last week. But that was Woods's game. If you gave him space, he had speed, good agility, and good vision. But he wasn't like Kupp or Puka where he could create something out of nothing.

The distinction I am making is very much not a "distinction without a difference" when the proposal was to change Woods's role to the Kupp and Puka role. But since you are so attached to the YAC per reception number, let's actually take a look at that stat for the three players. Here's what PFR shows for each guy:
Woods
2018: 4.9
2019: 6.4
2020: 5.5
2021: 4.4
2022: 2.9
2023: 3.2
2024: 3.7

Kupp
2018: 7.6
2019: 5.7
2020: 5.7
2021: 5.8
2022: 5.6
2023: 5.5
2024: 4.0
2025: 6.2
2026: 3.7

Puka
2023: 6.1
2024: 6.6
2025: 5.2
2026: 5.4

As I said, Woods wasn't the YAC threat Kupp and Puka are/were.
 
Last edited:
  • Thread Winner
  • High Five
Reactions: Ram65 and PARAM
Yeah that was a reassuring statement from one of the NFLs most experienced players.

And this is why today we don't have to be concerned about attracting talent.

And this starts with upper management. In the past 10 years the Rams has given much confidence in the high level quality of an organization we as fans have not seen since Georgia killed her husband. (Jury still out).
The 1983 documentary "An Unauthorized History of the NFL" examined ties between organized crime, gambling, and professional football. It raised compelling suspicions about the 1979 drowning of Los Angeles Rams owner Carroll Rosenbloom, suggesting he may have been murdered—and implicating his widow, Georgia Frontiere
 
Memphis proposed taking Woods out of the role he thrived in and putting him in the Kupp and Puka role. That would have required Woods to break more tackles, something he wasn't good at it. As I said to Memphis, Woods would have been very productive in that role because of his athleticism and route running, but he wouldn't have been as good as Puka or Kupp because he did not have their YAC ability.
Actually I wasn't proposing putting Woods in the same exact role. These are different types of WRs. My point was in regards to him having the same number of targets.
 
Actually I wasn't proposing putting Woods in the same exact role. These are different types of WRs. My point was in regards to him having the same number of targets.
Understood. My point remains, though. When you're the top dog, you receive more attention. It would have shrunk the space Woods had, which is how he generally created YAC. He still would have been highly productive. As productive as Kupp or Puka? I don't think so. Regardless, if the point is that Puka can be replaced, we're in agreement. I'd prefer not to replace him, but he is replaceable.