Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
I agree Puka has to put himself first here. He might be a bit salty with previous contract conversations we are not privy to...maybe what his agent is feeding him. He knows his value as the best WR in the game and he would be stupid not to shut it down now.

The Rams have the money to pay Puka long term. They are just going to have to sacrifice resigning some other key players. Turner will likely be gone along with Young and maybe some of the OGs. One of the guards and Turner/Young are replaceable.

Stafford might hang it up as well.
I'm sure they could structure his contract a certain way to pay him and maximize their chances of keeping some of our other FAs but they really seem to have dropped the ball there. Maybe things will change closer to the free agency deadline but you should pay superstars like Puka. Its a damn shame that it seems like Puka's having to decide to protect himself because the Rams don't want to financially commit to someone that has been a stud with them the whole time. Should have already paid the man.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DzRams and Steve808
I'm sure they could structure his contract a certain way to pay him and maximize their chances of keeping some of our other FAs but they really seem to have dropped the ball there. Maybe things will change closer to the free agency deadline but you should pay superstars like Puka. Its a damn shame that it seems like Puka's having to decide to protect himself because the Rams don't want to financially commit to someone that has been a stud with them the whole time. Should have already paid the man.
Yea kinda hard to commit to 160M when hes out biting ears and making antisemetic remarks. The lack of judgement obviously forced them to pause, plus wanting to see what the full investigation, league suspension would be.

If feels like they used his situation as leverage to get another cheap year out of him and to buy time to see if he could get his shit together.

If your 20 year old went out and did some stupid shit then asked to borrow the expensive car you might say no not right now. Both to teach a lesson and because you are not absolutely sure hes not going to do something stupid with the expensive car.
 
Yea kinda hard to commit to 160M when hes out biting ears and making antisemetic remarks. The lack of judgement obviously forced them to pause, plus wanting to see what the full investigation, league suspension would be.

If feels like they used his situation as leverage to get another cheap year out of him and to buy time to see if he could get his shit together.
He's been fine since then but hey, they'll pay a sorry ass WR like Allen Robinson money. I honestly don't understand why they'd risk getting another cheap year. I'm sure they could have put a clause in his contract to save money if he didn't conduct himself properly. I get its a risk to sign him to a long term contract (which really is the case with anyone) but to me, he's well worth it. Puka is a top star in this league.
 
All true. But given what Puka has put the team through, if he chose himself here, yeah, I don't like it, and I don't imagine the team likes it either.

Sure, Puka made a mistake last offseason, but I don't think it's accurate to characterize that as putting the team through anything when he's suffered the consequences of his action when the team chose not to extend him before the season. That lack of security is already payment for what he did to the team.

He accepted that consequence, played hard, putting his body on the line more than typical for a WR every game.

And now with a significant injury, his entire future is at risk. It's unreasonable to ask or demand that he risk $150+ mil from a permanent injury. Such entitlement.

I don't think it matters if the team likes it or not. If I'm Puka and the team is mad, f 'em.
 
  • High Five
Reactions: El Chapo Jr
I'm sure they could structure his contract a certain way to pay him and maximize their chances of keeping some of our other FAs but they really seem to have dropped the ball there. Maybe things will change closer to the free agency deadline but you should pay superstars like Puka. Its a damn shame that it seems like Puka's having to decide to protect himself because the Rams don't want to financially commit to someone that has been a stud with them the whole time. Should have already paid the man.

I agree. To be honest, I didn't agree with the team's decision to not extend him because of his off the field issue.

I feel like the whole thing was overstated and not enough to warrant not investing in him given there has been zero issue with his on-the-field effort and performance.

I did understand their decision, just didn't agree with it. Things going badly in negotiations with Puka is one of the foreseeable results of their decision. The team will have to live with the consequence of that decision.
 
  • High Five
Reactions: El Chapo Jr
Puka has every right to protect his future pay day.
The Rams have every right not to like it.

Puka may have kept his nose clean since his public embarrassing issues.
Then again, Puka may have also done some things the Rams know about that haven't gotten out yet.

Puka may have matured and will be on the straight and narrow from here on out.
If not, adding millions of $$$ to Puka or anyone who may be struggling with character issues is like adding gasoline to a fire.

Puka has been a great LA Rams player. If he's willing, I wouldn't mind seeing him play on the franchise tag next season in my role as imaginary GM. However, IMO, making Puka the highest paid WR in the NFL next off season would be a horrible decision. Tag and trade him and let another team make that mistake. And use the monies saved to build the best OLine possible for Ty Simpson.
 
Puka has every right to protect his future pay day.
The Rams have every right not to like it.

Puka may have kept his nose clean since his public embarrassing issues.
Then again, Puka may have also done some things the Rams know about that haven't gotten out yet.

Puka may have matured and will be on the straight and narrow from here on out.
If not, adding millions of $$$ to Puka or anyone who may be struggling with character issues is like adding gasoline to a fire.

Puka has been a great LA Rams player. If he's willing, I wouldn't mind seeing him play on the franchise tag next season in my role as imaginary GM. However, IMO, making Puka the highest paid WR in the NFL next off season would be a horrible decision. Tag and trade him and let another team make that mistake. And use the monies saved to build the best OLine possible for Ty Simpson.

Why a horrible decision? Not just a slightly bad one?
Why a mistake?
What are you imagining would go wrong?

Is this take mostly because you don't believe WRs are worth $40+ mil?
 
If not, adding millions of $$$ to Puka or anyone who may be struggling with character issues is like adding gasoline to a fire.


1795326495738.webp


.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Memphis Ram
Why a horrible decision? Not just a slightly bad one?
Why a mistake?
What are you imagining would go wrong?

Is this take mostly because you don't believe WRs are worth $40+ mil?
Yes. I don't care what the market may say. I simply don't believe that WRs are worth $40+ million per year.

I believe that after RB it's probably the easiest position to fill and that a great deal of success can be had via a good WR who (and this is very important) is on the same page with his QB.
 
Final thought for the night.

IMO, if Robert Woods were given Cooper Kupp's targets playing in the slot or could somehow be 25 again and given Puka targets today we'd be talking about how great (not just good) he was/is.
 
  • High Five
Reactions: BC Ramfan
Yes. I don't care what the market may say. I simply don't believe that WRs are worth $40+ million per year.

I believe that after RB it's probably the easiest position to fill and that a great deal of success can be had via a good WR who (and this is very important) is on the same page with his QB.
When Puka was out only DA was catching passes. Same when Puka was in. Seattle has the same issue with any WR not JSN. Offense is a joke until they get the ball to him. Mahomes with Hill was a different QB. The list goes on.

Given, its a team sport and Oline and QB are massive to the equation.

I think especially in Puka's case we have seen at times he is the Rams only offense in crunch time.

Can you eventually find a Julian Edelman that can catch 10 catches a game in crunch time? Yes, but not sure those guys grow on trees.


Maybe a rookie like CJ Daniels emerges in the next 7+ games. But relying on the others or old man DA going forward does not seem wise.

Rams best option to me seems to be to pay Puka his 160M. Stretch it out so you can resign key players. Turner and Young are more easily replaceable. Turner wasnt really missed to be honest and Young can disappear for long stretches. I think you sign Avila or Dotson and let the other walk and roll with one of your backups such as Deidich or Limmer. We have another season or two to make a run with this defense and Stafford/Puka and the RB's.
 
We all do know that Puka is replaceable.

Especially a damaged Puka.

I for one is facing NFL reality.

It was fun while it lasted.

And he is not the only 100 mil highly serviceable free agent this off season.

Then the draft.

This season turned out like shit during the first game.

Next year is just as important.

GO RAMS!!!
 
We all do know that Puka is replaceable.

Especially a damaged Puka.

I for one is facing NFL reality.

It was fun while it lasted.

And he is not the only 100 mil highly serviceable free agent this off season.

Then the draft.

This season turned out like shit during the first game.

Next year is just as important.

GO RAMS!!!

I don't think anyone at his level is remotely available this year in Free Agency unless you mean the draft in the late rounds.

Top Tier:
Pickens (no thanks)

Next Tier
Parker Washington
Tre Tucker
Rashee Rice
 
Final thought for the night.

IMO, if Robert Woods were given Cooper Kupp's targets playing in the slot or could somehow be 25 again and given Puka targets today we'd be talking about how great (not just good) he was/is.
He would have produced. Sure. But he wouldn't have produced to the level Kupp and Puka did. Why? Woods wasn't the YAC threat they are or were. Regardless, you are right that Puka is not irreplaceable. Still, I think we should tag him. He's a valuable player. At minimum, it would be smart to have another year to figure out life after Puka if we're moving on.
 
He would have produced. Sure. But he wouldn't have produced to the level Kupp and Puka did. Why? Woods wasn't the YAC threat they are or were. Regardless, you are right that Puka is not irreplaceable. Still, I think we should tag him. He's a valuable player. At minimum, it would be smart to have another year to figure out life after Puka if we're moving on.
Ummmm…

You might want to pull up YAC numbers.. especially 2019 & 20…

Woods was absolutely a YAC stud.
 
Ummmm…

You might want to pull up YAC numbers.. especially 2019 & 20…

Woods was absolutely a YAC stud.
Ummmm... I watched the guy play. He wasn't in Kupp and Puka's league in terms of YAC. His good YAC numbers in those years were largely scheme. Using Pro Football Reference's broken tackle numbers, Woods had a TOTAL of 7 broken tackles between 2018 and 2021 (i.e., his entire Rams career, aside from 2017 - PFR doesn't have the numbers for 2017). Cooper Kupp broke 12 tackles in 2020 alone. Puka broke 11 tackles in 2025 alone.

So don't try to revise history. I remember those years well.
 
  • Cheers
  • Like
Reactions: DzRams and PARAM
Ummmm... I watched the guy play. He wasn't in Kupp and Puka's league in terms of YAC. His good YAC numbers in those years were largely scheme. Using Pro Football Reference's broken tackle numbers, Woods had a TOTAL of 7 broken tackles between 2018 and 2021 (i.e., his entire Rams career, aside from 2017 - PFR doesn't have the numbers for 2017). Cooper Kupp broke 12 tackles in 2020 alone. Puka broke 11 tackles in 2025 alone.

So don't try to revise history. I remember those years well.

View: https://giphy.com/gifs/paramountnetwork-paramount-network-wife-swap-lowAWCxGXbl5vVlrWH
 
Although I'm a Rams fan, fuck what the team thinks. If Puka feels this is best for his long term health and career, its the best decision to make. He's coming up on free agency and McVay leaned on him hard and would do so once he came back. Again, the Rams really fucked up by not bringing any kind of veteran help. Really baffling and stupid on their part. With thet said, this team still has the opportunity in front of them to go far but its going to be a lot harder now without an elite weapon like Puka.
In addition to that, if the Rams don't resign him (he'll likely cost more now for at least a couple of reasons), everything that happens with this roster down the road, good or bad, will be squarely on management for that decision. This is assuming that Puka wants to be a Ram of course.
You do not let a player with Nacua's abilities walk, if you are to be taken seriously as a winning organization.
And don't bring up his last off season's (alleged) bad judgement as potential justification for not coming to an agreement. There are plenty of examples of worse cases of bad judgement by NFL players and in most of these situations, the teams stick with their guy.
 
  • High Five
Reactions: El Chapo Jr
He would have produced. Sure. But he wouldn't have produced to the level Kupp and Puka did. Why? Woods wasn't the YAC threat they are or were. Regardless, you are right that Puka is not irreplaceable. Still, I think we should tag him. He's a valuable player. At minimum, it would be smart to have another year to figure out life after Puka if we're moving on.
I'd argue that YAC yards loss via perhaps fewer broken tackles could possibly be made up by being clearly faster than both of them.
 
I don't think anyone at his level is remotely available this year in Free Agency unless you mean the draft in the late rounds.

Top Tier:
Pickens (no thanks)

Next Tier
Parker Washington
Tre Tucker
Rashee Rice
Parker Washington is a beast, gives 110% every play but Jacksonville won't let him walk