Here's my issue:
1) Not recently. He got injured and hasn't been the same since. He was the least effective WR in football last year.
2) While true, his amazing start to the year in 2011 that people always cite came after Fisher was fired.
3) Possibly but I don't really feel like we have a lot of veteran leadership in our locker-room. This is a pretty young team. And there's potential there for Britt to be a bad influence on our young guys.
I agree with everything you said Minus number 3. If our guys as adults, can't make their own decisions and are willing to jeopardize their careers because Kenny Britt influenced them we have far bigger issues. At the end of the day "bad influences" are everywhere, especially when your a 20 something year old millionaire with a high profile job they will be influenced to make poor choices at some point regardless and it will be up to them and them alone to proceed.
That being said, everyone of your points is valid, it is entirely possible he's done, he's still a head case, etc.. but it is also entirely possible he's matured, fisher knows how to use him, etc... the potential is there, he's shown flashes of it, what he choses to do with it/what happens next is up in the air. And as i mentioned before, that kenny britt that looked so promising a few years ago would be the best WR on our team
and that brings us full circle, if both scenarios are entirely plausible, and the cost of seeing the outcome is very low, why would you oppose such a move?