- Joined
- Feb 6, 2019
- Messages
- 3,963
These are dentists. 4/5 as the tiny dancer will continue to shrink IMHO.Save y'all the view...
1. J Daniels
2. J Love
3. J. Herbert
4. K. Murray
5. CJ Stroud
it's funny, their games are so different but I can't help comparing Herbert to Philip Rivers, great QB but just never elite. Can't will a team to a win. You watch what he can do with the football and how he can activate everything on the field with his arm strength, touch and accuracy but there's still something missing. Harbaugh seems to have been good for him so far....Murray is going in to his 7th year, Herbert his 6th, neither guy has won a playoff game. Both guy seemed to have regressed from when they came in to the league. Love going in to his 6th year and also seemed to regress.
Elite? Stroud was great as a rookie, stepped back as a 2nd year, will see what year 3 holds. As for Daniels? Stroud is the example of not jumping too soon on a player's band wagon.
Elite to me is HOF bound type players Mahomes/Allen/Burrow, I dont see any of those 5 joining this short list
And yes, Stafford is Elite and HOF bound, but not included because we're talking over the next 5 years or so
Herbert just doesnt do it for me, even back to his college days. Rivers in my mind was a sniper and unfortunately ran in to the Patriots a bunch of times in the playoffs. I see what you're saying but at least he won 5 playoff games, 4 in his first 5 years where Herbert hasnt won one yet in 6 seasons, blowing a 27-0 lead in 1 game and throwing 4 picks in a 2nd lossit's funny, their games are so different but I can't help comparing Herbert to Philip Rivers, great QB but just never elite. Can't will a team to a win. You watch what he can do with the football and how he can activate everything on the field with his arm strength, touch and accuracy but there's still something missing. Harbaugh seems to have been good for him so far....
Yeah great point about playoffsHerbert just doesnt do it for me, even back to his college days. Rivers in my mind was a sniper and unfortunately ran in to the Patriots a bunch of times in the playoffs. I see what you're saying but at least he won 5 playoff games, 4 in his first 5 years where Herbert hasnt won one yet in 6 seasons, blowing a 27-0 lead in 1 game and throwing 4 picks in a 2nd loss
The keeper league I am in I joined back when it was on paper as well, 25 years ago or so.My two fantasy QB's are Jayden Daniels (Keeper) and Jordan Love. Been in this league for 30 years (we started it with paper) and have won Ten Titles. Kids were involved early because they knew if I won, it meant more Christmas Presents and now the Grandchildren are on board too.
Orlovsky is about as perceptive as the average fan you might find at the bar.Save y'all the view...
1. J Daniels
2. J Love
3. J. Herbert
4. K. Murray
5. CJ Stroud
That is awesome, what is nice about this particular league is we still meet in person although a couple of the guys now reside down south (lucky them) and they either come back because we always do the draft on Labor Day (Thank you Grover Cleveland) or virtual as all of us have our devices of our choice we utilize during the draft and we hold at a Marriott most of the time.The keeper league I am in I joined back when it was on paper as well, 25 years ago or so.
Now have players on the east coast, west coast, rockies, Sierra Nevada and the Deep South.
12 teams spread all over.
Its fun and after a quarter century or so finally won my first title last year.....haha.
NOW, I can rest on my laurels.