Using 2 kickers and Rams Special Teams

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Not sure what happened this game or if McV has spoken to it - but not a great game for this little experiment.

33 (returned)
35 (kicked into the endzone)
40 (short of the landing zone)
35 (into the end zone - 13 seconds left in the half)
40 (out of bounds)
35 (endzone)
35 (endzone)

36.1 average starting field position this game
Regression. True. But if there was ever a game you could get away with it..........
Clearly, still work to do.
 
If he was told by the coach to boot it to the endzone on the kicks where he did - which seems really likely - then it would change the nexus for me

In that case you have one that got returned, one that missed the landing zone, and one that barely went out of bounds. The out of bounds one was potentially dangerous though …..

I wonder why the brass decided to tell him to just boot it. Or - if that call didn’t come from coaching - why he decided to abandon the dirty.
I'm sure the coaches told Karty how to kick. No way he made those decisions on his own.

So out of 7 kickoffs, there were 4 times he was told to boot it into the EZ (for a start at the 35).

In my view, Karty was successful on 2 of 3 "dirty" attempts. One was a horrible mis-kick that landed well short of the landing zone, and looked really bad -- a glaring error. But the other 2 kicks were successful in my opinion-- they dropped into the landing zone and were difficult to handle. On one, the returner corralled it after one bounce and got a good return to the 33. On the other, the ball took some weird bounces and almost landed at the 2 yard line. IMO, you take that kick every time.

I'm concerned that Karty might be a head case. But he's had enough success with the dirty kick that I think they should keep doing it. We'll know more in a couple weeks.

Last thing-- even if heaven forbid the ball doesn't make it to the landing zone, having the ball placed at the 40 is only 5 yards worse than the supposedly "safe" option of blasting it through the EZ. If a team is gonna try the dirty kick, it's inevitable that occasionally there will be flags to place the ball at the 40. IMO, the dirty kick option is still way better than the crap the Rams were doing in weeks 1-7.
 
I'm sure the coaches told Karty how to kick. No way he made those decisions on his own.

So out of 7 kickoffs, there were 4 times he was told to boot it into the EZ (for a start at the 35).

In my view, Karty was successful on 2 of 3 "dirty" attempts. One was a horrible mis-kick that landed well short of the landing zone, and looked really bad -- a glaring error. But the other 2 kicks were successful in my opinion-- they dropped into the landing zone and were difficult to handle. On one, the returner corralled it after one bounce and got a good return to the 33. On the other, the ball took some weird bounces and almost landed at the 2 yard line. IMO, you take that kick every time.

I'm concerned that Karty might be a head case. But he's had enough success with the dirty kick that I think they should keep doing it. We'll know more in a couple weeks.

Last thing-- even if heaven forbid the ball doesn't make it to the landing zone, having the ball placed at the 40 is only 5 yards worse than the supposedly "safe" option of blasting it through the EZ. If a team is gonna try the dirty kick, it's inevitable that occasionally there will be flags to place the ball at the 40. IMO, the dirty kick option is still way better than the crap the Rams were doing in weeks 1-7.
I 100% agree. We were giving up field position frequently past the 40 yard line due to our crappy special teams coverage on kickoff returns. If the worst field position is going to be the 40 - keep doing it. Better than giving the opponent our 25 yard line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: XXXIVwin
Kicking that dirty kick is risky. In order to accomplish the desired outcome it's got to land very close to the 20. You want it bouncing or more accurately skidding in between the 2 returners. So sometimes it'll fall short. It was effective early in the year and it'll be affective going forward.
 
  • Like
Reactions: modern eagle
With Shelton going down for a month or more you wonder how that will work with trying to have two kickers active on gameday. We may have to expose a player on the practice squad in order to have the right group called up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: XXXIVwin
Here are the number comparisons since he came back. Fact is Rams are doing better even with a 2 of 3 missed landing this week. In total he had 2 just missed the landing zone by 1 yard out of 16 attempts. So I'm inclined to see a little more attempts. The Rams coverage team was and still needs big improvement.

___________________________
Los Angeles Rams kicker Joshua Karty has appeared in 3 games (Weeks 8–10) exclusively as a kickoff specialist, attempting 16 kickoffs with opponents averaging a 31.5-yard line starting field position—a 3.2-yard improvement compared to the 34.7-yard line opponents averaged against Los Angeles before Karty rejoined the lineup.
Bottom line for me is he missed on 5 of 6 kicks last Sunday, giving the Cards the ball at the 35 three times and the 40 twice.
There's no sugar coating that.
If it happens in a (potential) playoff game, I'm pissed.
 
Bottom line for me is he missed on 5 of 6 kicks last Sunday, giving the Cards the ball at the 35 three times and the 40 twice.
There's no sugar coating that.
If it happens in a (potential) playoff game, I'm pissed.

Who is sugar coating?

I gave you the field position numbers since he started which are better by 3.1 yards per KO. Better is better.

McManus kicked against Vegas the first 2 drives started at the 50 and 38 yard lines. Then he just kicked into the end zone 4 times. Ave. 38 yard line.

It's going to get down to the roster spot. If Karty's spot is needed then McManus will most likely KO into the endzone. Drives will start at the 35 yard line.

We will see what happens.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ram Ts
Bottom line for me is he missed on 5 of 6 kicks last Sunday, giving the Cards the ball at the 35 three times and the 40 twice.
There's no sugar coating that.
If it happens in a (potential) playoff game, I'm pissed.
He missed on two. The other 3 he was ordered to kick into the end zone. Not on him.

And the second one was a great kick that had the unluckiness of having a bad bounce that came too near the foul line.

That one bad kick though - ouch. Probably caused the order to kick into the end zone.
 
Who is sugar coating?

I gave you the field position numbers since he started which are better by 3.1 yards per KO. Better is better.

McManus kicked against Vegas the first 2 drives started at the 50 and 38 yard lines. Then he just kicked into the end zone 4 times. Ave. 38 yard line.

It's going to get down to the roster spot. If Karty's spot is needed then McManus will most likely KO into the endzone. Drives will start at the 35 yard line.

We will see what happens.
Didn't know I was implying anyone was, it's just a phrase there.
 
Guess I missed that he was ordered to do that.
Where did you see that?
You seriously think Karty is out there doing whatever he wants without specific instructions lol.
Even established kickers are told what to do. But Karty even more so. If he did something on his own, he’d be told to take a seat and find a new job after the game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: XXXIVwin
Guess I missed that he was ordered to do that.
Where did you see that?
Just by the way he approached the ball you could tell he was going to kick it into the end zone.

Completely different approach to kicking the ball.

And for him to do the different approach - he had to have been ordered to kick it into the end zone.

He wouldn't have changed his approach if not told to do that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: XXXIVwin
You seriously think Karty is out there doing whatever he wants without specific instructions lol.
Even established kickers are told what to do. But Karty even more so. If he did something on his own, he’d be told to take a seat and find a new job after the game.
I think he's trying to hit it just inside of the landing zone each KO, not near the sideline, with it landing unusually and taking strange bounces.
Some land inside of the 5 and go into or through the end zone, which isn't an optimum situation.
Punters shank some kicks, and kick off guys don't always place them where they want to place them.
But I'll go along with your position until someone proves it otherwise.
With Karty, the whole idea was not to have to kick it into or out of the end zone.
Hell, Mevis could do that.
 
I think he's trying to hit it just inside of the landing zone each KO, not near the sideline, with it landing unusually and taking strange bounces.

Some land inside of the 5 and go into or through the end zone, which isn't an optimum situation.
Actually, hitting inside the 5 and then going out of the endzone is ideal. That puts it on the 20. If he kicks it right out of the endzone, without landing inside the landing zone first, then that puts it on the 35.
 
Actually, hitting inside the 5 and then going out of the endzone is ideal. That puts it on the 20. If he kicks it right out of the endzone, without landing inside the landing zone first, then that puts it on the 35.
Forgive me for asking a VERY stupid question. But is it THAT hard, for a professional kicker, who has 4-5 DAYS of Practice before a game, to kick a Football, on a fly, within a 20 f***ing yard landing radius????!!!!! These guys should be doing it IN THEIR SLEEP come gameday!!!!!
 
  • High Five
  • Like
Reactions: David Ray and dpjax
Forgive me for asking a VERY stupid question. But is it THAT hard, for a professional kicker, who has 4-5 DAYS of Practice before a game, to kick a Football, on a fly, within a 20 f***ing yard landing radius????!!!!! These guys should be doing it IN THEIR SLEEP come gameday!!!!!
It’s the way they kick it. They are kicking a screwball - the point isn’t to get it to land in the zone and nothing more - it is to make it hard to catch either in the air or off the ground.
 
It’s the way they kick it. They are kicking a screwball - the point isn’t to get it to land in the zone and nothing more - it is to make it hard to catch either in the air or off the ground.
Just kick it in the 20-yard radius. Let em freakin catch it. Very simple. In practice, Tues thru Fri practice kicking on a fly to land on the 10-5 yard line. Better to kick it IN the end zone (35) than pre-20 (40). Thats if I even have the rule correctly. What a shitshow the League has made of this kickoff, SMH.
 
When we kick it in the zone and let them catch it, they run it past midfield sometimes. Thats the whole point. The 40 isn’t great but we were averaging the 35 before Karty came back. Out of bounds or missing the landing zone isn’t a nightmare if it’s only 5 yards away from the old average. The returns that put them in field goal position by themselves are what needs to be avoided at all cost.

That - more than anything - is why I think we are watching this experiment.
 
I think he's trying to hit it just inside of the landing zone each KO
Respectfully, I think you are totally wrong on this.

In the Cards game, Karty had two entirely different techniques for kickoffs.

On four occasions, Karty was clearly instructed to kick the ball into or beyond the EZ for a touchback to the 35. (There's no way on earth Karty would decide this on his own-- this is clearly a coaching strategy decision). On these 4 "blast it" KO's, Karty has a longer approach, at a greater angle, and the trajectory of the ball is high.

On the 3 other occasions, Karty tried the "dirty kick." For these, he has a shorter approach, at a more straight-on angle, with a very "straight and flat" technique at contact point. Crucially, the ball leaves the tee at a very flat angle and with a much lower trajectory. The goal is to have the ball "knuckle" in the air with unpredictable flight path and unpredictable bounce.

Karty had one terrible dirty kick, admittedly. But on 2 occasions he placed the ball exactly where he intended. (It just so happened that one kick had some unlucky bounces-- but "unpredictable bounces" are a part of the purpose of the dirty kick.)