It's bizarre handling of the players. Cooks get huge extension, dumped a year later. Arob? Big contract, dumped season later. Gurley? Totally bizarre ending. Not arguing with the success but it sure come off that with certain positions/players they fall out of favor and poof are gone. Cooks, Gurley and Robinson hurt the cap, werent cost saves.
Bizarre handling of players goes back with this regime and front office tbh. Remember them paying Ogletree before they had fully gotten Wade's approval on him? That seemed like it was a situation of the front office inking him without making sure everyone was on the same page. Then the sudden reversal and he's dealt.
I think Cooks was simply McVay thinking "this isn't the guy" and being frustrated by the failure in the big game. Same with Goff and Gurley. Gurley in particular he backed during that Super Bowl run there at the end and didn't give the better RB the carries during the SB and I still think it might have cost him a title. Goff felt a bit like Ogletree to me, where maybe the front office got the deal done when McVay was still sorting what went wrong.
Robinson I still think was just too old and set in his ways, maybe even too stupid, to learn the nuance in this offense. That's definitely one of the misses I was fully behind.
But overall if you line up the production vs decisions McVay has been at his worst with the RB room. His decision making with that room has been fucking terrible. IMO. Great coach. Hall of Fame future and I think he is the best in today's league but he's human and has plenty of flaws. For example RB and OL feel like positions where, if he doesn't have a top coach in place, he is flying blind a lot of times.