Rams: (#13) 1st Round QB Ty Simpson

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Explain how that article confirms your expertise in body language, whereby you told us McVay was clearly pissed off at the presser and couldn’t hide it?

I quote, “He could still look at little happy about the pick. And that little forced smile he executed was priceless”

While you are at it, please confirm whether you are 12 years old :-)
1777061997877.webp
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheTackle
Funny how so many people loved 6'1 Baker Mayfield and would have loved having him back and yet Ty Simpson is now undersized at 6'1+
If Ty Simpson had 37 SEC starts under his belt, I wouldn’t give a rats ass how tall he was. I’d say “sign me up!”. Baker Mayfield was a 3 year starter in college. He won the Heisman. He proved consistently he could play at a high level. Simpson hasn’t shown that. He played one season and was hurt for half of it. I think the size questions are fair, but the lack of reps bothers me significantly more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Giles
No we should definitely be worried because there’s not a track record of QBs with this little amount of playing experience working out. Outside of Cam Newton it literally doesn’t exist. And Ty Simpson isn’t exactly Cam Newton.

Dwyane Haskins, Mac Jones, Trey Lance, Mitchell Trubisky, Ryan Tannehill, Anthony Richardson, Kyler Murray to name a few of the busts.
OK that’s a different argument

I don’t have a response other than they didn’t seem too concerned when they took him 13th so time will tell

I worry more about his injuries last year having only played 15 games but feel he is young and will get bigger, stronger, and make better decisions. Let’s hope he’s more Joe Montana than Sam Bradford. Both took a battering but the smaller man was tough as nails
 
Last edited:
If the Rams need a wr so badly then why did they let Tutu walk?

Because Tutu is not the answer for the #3 receiver spot and never has been. We trotted out Mumpfield and Whittington above Atwell, and aside from the Colts game, he made little impact with only six receptions. That should tell you all you need to know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheTackle
I really have nothing interesting to share.

It has been rather entertaining, as it is every year, reading all the shake down perspectives with this pick.

So the way I look at this as there are choices. There is one hell of an upside here if I continue to trust the ones that have earned my trust unlike any other Rams staff in history.

I have my questions but there is one thing that is 100% about Simpson. Our Rams organization all signed off on this pick. Don't try and fool yourself otherwise. They see this as the best path to continue our rather recent new experience of being a consistently winning franchise. Unlike any other time by far during my 43 years of being a Rams fanatic.

It will be really sweet if Ty becomes our franchise QB we all hope for at any point of time of our tenure as Rams fans.

Not nearly as sweet if you don't even give our beloved Rams management a chance.

I say there is a better chance than not Ty is going to make us VERY happy.

Saw a bunch of film on Ty these past 20 hours or so. I personally see his up side.

GO RAMS!!!
 
Any chance they now move Bennett for a late rd pick swap or a bag of balls? The Cards QB situation is a mess, LaFleur could use a guy who can help the other QBs learn the system.

Then the Rams could go get Tyrod Taylor so they have a vet back up for a year, who could also help Simpson.
Doubt they could get anything for him, and he might be useful in camp and the preseason. He knows the offense well and Stafford will probably have a light load before the season starts.
 
Sure, the end result is the same statistically. It goes deeper than that though. A typical successful Rams scoring drive looks like Stafford’s arm and Puka acrobatics moving the chains 80 yards to paydirt and Kyren punching it in 2 yards out.

A lot can go wrong with that model. More to the point, that’s a lot of pressure on the QB and playcaller to sustain these long drives with almost no threat of your RB, TE or WR taking one of those 10 or 12 plays to the house so your 38 yr old QB can go sit down.

As to your question, these playmakers are available nearly every year. Draft, FA, traded. The Rams since ‘22 have appeared to value other football traits much higher than pure playmaking. That strategy has worked in terms of rebuilding the roster quickly with solid players. My point is that as of today, it’s time to pivot a bit from that and inject traits that this offense simply doesn’t have.

Im not sure how half of the fanbase doesn’t see that. I assume they watch other games and offenses. This is a slowish, deliberate offense that is so reliant on Stafford and Puka to make plays and score. Besides Puka there are no players on offense who can regularly win one on one or strike fear into a defense. It wins with execution, solid players and an elite QB but it’s flawed.
McVay and his coaches have done an incredible job here.

Maybe step back and look at it objectively.

I don’t hate the Simpson player at all. I watched almost 4 hrs of material on him last night before bedtime. Including the QB school episode with Gruden. Simpson was impressive. He needs more coaching and he’ll get it.

I don’t like the pick at 13 in this draft, this year.
A good post - but consider:
- We all had QB penciled in the first round of this draft, from the day after we traded down for ATL's 1st.
- Simpson's floor was 16, Jets - who took Sadiq. I believe they woulda taken Simpson instead there.
- So his value at 13? pretty good, he's the #2 QB rated in this draft, and no one would've been surprised if AZ took him at #3 overall.
- We both know the Rams still need some real playmakers -- thankfully there's quite a few left with true 2nd round grades, including Washington Jr. if we wanna burner at RB.
 
If Ty Simpson had 37 SEC starts under his belt, I wouldn’t give a rats ass how tall he was. I’d say “sign me up!”. Baker Mayfield was a 3 year starter in college. He won the Heisman. He proved consistently he could play at a high level. Simpson hasn’t shown that. He played one season and was hurt for half of it. I think the size questions are fair, but the lack of reps bothers me significantly more.
The lack of reps and not being able to beat out milroe is what's most concerning for me. On top of not being very good if and when he does start let's say 2 years from now he'll have spent way more time on the bench than playing football and getting better from college to the nfl. That's a big issue for me especially with McVay who throws alot of information at his qbs expecting them to take said info and apply it on the field. I fear he'll lose patience fast with Simpson and it won't even be Simpson fault.
 
Doubt they could get anything for him, and he might be useful in camp and the preseason. He knows the offense well and Stafford will probably have a light load before the season starts.
Thats true.
 
Explain how that article confirms your expertise in body language, whereby you told us McVay was clearly pissed off at the presser and couldn’t hide it?

I quote, “He could still look at little happy about the pick. And that little forced smile he executed was priceless”

While you are at it, please confirm whether you are 12 years old :-)

Honey, go to the very top of page 40 and read if you're able.

It appears you must be around 5 years old, so I'm not sure how advanced you are in the reading department.

But hey, you do you.
 
The lack of reps and not being able to beat out milroe is what's most concerning for me. On top of not being very good if and when he does start let's say 2 years from now he'll have spent way more time on the bench than playing football and getting better from college to the nfl. That's a big issue for me especially with McVay who throws alot of information at his qbs expecting them to take said info and apply it on the field. I fear he'll lose patience fast with Simpson and it won't even be Simpson fault.
Projecting QBs is maybe the single hardest thing front offices do. Even the greatest coaches and scouts miss on guys. The bust rate on first round QBs is extremely high.

But there are 2 statistics in recent years that have cut thru the noise and proven to be good indicators of how well a QB will translate to the NFL. And they are number of games played, and number of sacks taken. QBs that take a lot of sacks in college tend to get to the NFL and do the same thing. And QBs with extensive experience—I’m talking 35-40+ starts—especially in big boy football conferences like the SEC or Big 10, have done much better than developmental projects with little experience that got drafted off potential. Brock Purdy, Bo Nix, and Jayden Daniels are perfect examples. Physically not as gifted as their peers but the mental Rolodex created from all those game reps give them an enormous mental advantage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JonRam99 and Giles
I actually think Simpson has more arm talent than Purdy, but Purdy played in 48(!!) games at Iowa State. He literally had more than 3x the game reps Simpson did. And that’s why Purdy is a good QB. Theres nothing physically exceptional about him. But he’s played in a million games. That type of experience is invaluable.
 
I swear, the silliest critique I hear about Simpson is the lack of starts or reps. People may have good reasons for thinking he won't succeed. That ain't one of them. If that's the best criticism you have, the guy must be a damn good prospect. It's no different than these silly critiques from the past:
"Don't draft Patrick Mahomes. Air Raid QBs never succeed."
"Don't draft Russell Wilson. Short QBs never succeed."
"Don't draft Drew Brees. Spread QBs never succeed."