Puka Injury Thread (merged)

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.
Again.. simply not answering the question.

Also.. terribly flawed argument.. it’s like you don’t know the difference between 11 personnel and 13 personnel.

Or the difference in a primary zone scheme vs what they run now.
Oh boy. You just like to be an ass don't you? Why bother anymore.

The first ROD poster I will put on ignore.
 
I was mentally prepared for both Nacua and Adams to be out a number of games this year. Adams due to age. Nacua due to playing style. I kinda hated how much Stafford relied on Nacua and seemed to force the ball to him way too much.
3 to 4 games without Nacua, forcing Stafford to utilize the TEs, Mumpfield, Tutu or Daniels seemed like a blessing in disguise. Allowing discovery of a more dynamic offense for an end of year playoff run.
Now The Rams need one more trick to cover not having Nacua for the rest of the year. As an overly optimistic Rams fan I have a glimmer of hope they’ll figure it out for a glorious finish/playoff run.
Go Rams!
 
So Shanahan is dumb for overusing McCafferey? Was SF dumb for adding 35 yr old Evans at WR?

Hell, they added a rookie WR at the top of rd 2 and he got hurt.

Just shows there are no guarantees in this sport and fans like you, who claim this and that would have happened with adding another WR, is just ridiculous.
McVay overused his top WR even when we had drafted two 2nd round receivers in Jefferson and Tutu. Overuse under McVay has never had a damn thing to do with roster construction.
 
So Shanahan is dumb for overusing McCafferey? Was SF dumb for adding 35 yr old Evans at WR?

Hell, they added a rookie WR at the top of rd 2 and he got hurt.

Just shows there are no guarantees in this sport and fans like you, who claim this and that would have happened with adding another WR, is just ridiculous.
“guarantees”…

Who is guaranteeing anything?

I’m talking probability and exercise science as it relates to usage and injury.

Build more straw men, though.
 
Except it’s not.

Someone who is an outlier in overuse is obviously a candidate for more injury.

It’s not even controversial or an opinion, it’s just fact.
Let's fire McVay because he targets Puka like Seattle targets JSN. Like Cincinnati targets Chase. Or like SF uses McCaffrey. These "facts" are so damning!!! Fact is, the superstars get used to the point of overuse. And if they didn't, fans would be screaming to use them more!! Catch-22.
 
McVay overused his top WR even when we had drafted two 2nd round receivers in Jefferson and Tutu. Overuse under McVay has never had a damn thing to do with roster construction.
I don't think Goff overused one WR. I think its more of a Stafford thing. You realize there are multiple eligible receivers on a given play. Nacua isn't always the primary on everyone of his targets. You can often see Stafford forcing him the ball. There are other guys out there on the field.
 
I don't think Goff overused one WR. I think its more of a Stafford thing. You realize there are multiple eligible receivers on a given play. Nacua isn't always the primary on everyone of his targets. You can often see Stafford forcing him the ball. There are other guys out there on the field.
Yes, this is indeed a Stafford thing. But McVay can change it.
 
“He always overuses his players”

Puka was on a 170 catch pace and running the ball at a rate closer to Robert Woods than Kupp.

And Puka’s avg depth of target this year is significantly lower.

So.. more hits from bigger players
 
  • Like
Reactions: David Ray
Let's fire McVay because he targets Puka like Seattle targets JSN. Like Cincinnati targets Chase. Or like SF uses McCaffrey. These "facts" are so damning!!! Fact is, the superstars get used to the point of overuse. And if they didn't, fans would be screaming to use them more!! Catch-22.
Yeah, I pointed that out the other day. JSN has over 1200 yrds receiving. The next highest on the team is Kupp with 272, on only 23 receptions. For the mathematically challenged, thats 2.3 receptions per game for 27 yds per game.

Sons a bitches are killing that kid!
 
  • Like
  • Cheers
Reactions: PARAM and RamBall
Yeah, I pointed that out the other day. JSN has over 1200 yrds receiving. The next highest on the team is Kupp with 272, on only 23 receptions. For the mathematically challenged, thats 2.3 receptions per game for 27 yds per game.

Sons a bitches are killing that kid!
JSN’s avg target depth is over 10 yards..
Puka’s is under 8.

I’ve already explained what that means in hits.
 
Yeah, I pointed that out the other day. JSN has over 1200 yrds receiving. The next highest on the team is Kupp with 272, on only 23 receptions. For the mathematically challenged, thats 2.3 receptions per game for 27 yds per game.

Sons a bitches are killing that kid!
But it only takes 1 hit to the knee and then JSN was over used.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PhillyRam
Oh… and I’ve never called for McVay to be fired or questioned his intelligence or any of that nonsense.

We’re fans.. we can question our team
 
McVay just can't help himself but run his best players into the ground.
I don’t disagree with you. The stats and eye test prove that out.

My argument has been that for the last few years there aren’t enough great/elite/playmakers on offense. My argument isn’t a full excuse for the reality that both Kupp and now Puka have been run into the ground. They were/are our best offensive players (by a country mile). Anyone who thinks that margin is less than that has blinders on. I can name those skill players(again) but no point.

I do believe that the inability to bring in high end talent over the course of a few seasons is one factor in terms of where we are today and why our best offensive players get worn out.

Other factors have been discussed.
 
I don't think Goff overused one WR. I think its more of a Stafford thing. You realize there are multiple eligible receivers on a given play. Nacua isn't always the primary on everyone of his targets. You can often see Stafford forcing him the ball. There are other guys out there on the field.
I agree with this. It doesn't seem that McVay has done anything to address it, though.
 
I don’t disagree with you. The stats and eye test prove that out.

My argument has been that for the last few years there aren’t enough great/elite/playmakers on offense. My argument isn’t a full excuse for the reality that both Kupp and now Puka have been run into the ground. They were/are our best offensive players (by a country mile). Anyone who thinks that margin is less than that has blinders on. I can name those skill players(again) but no point.

I do believe that the inability to bring in high end talent over the course of a few seasons is one factor in terms of where we are today and why our best offensive players get worn out.

Other factors have been discussed.
I don't think the margin is a country mile. Whenever Puka is out, Adams dominates.

Whether it's primarily Stafford or McVay at fault, two receiving options get 80-90% of the usage every year since we've had Stafford.
 
  • Like
Reactions: badnews
If it wasn't that Puka sweep to the right it would have been the next one. It's been that kind of season. Just beat Green Bay Rams and then think about the next game. I just hope this team can stick together for next season when they are all healthy. I love this Rams team. When healthy they could be a dynasty team. Oh yeah, I'm taking Tuesday off so I will be at my in laws on game night. Still not sure about green bean casserole though.
 
  • Cheers
Reactions: badnews
I’m glad Puka decided to undergo surgery. If the McVay/Rams were going to overwork him and not pay, he’s wise for trying to get healthy before free agency. McVay and Snead messed up by not addressing the WR room. They wanted a future QB in Simpson, fine. But why draft klare when we already use 4 TEs and then not even use him when the TEa get injured. The drafting strategy was poor. Glad this is happening so McVay feels like a total dick.