The reason that you throw the ball on both second and third down instead of going for a 48 yard field is that anything longer than 40 yards is reaching the limits of Mevis' range. That is why he has been wide on anything over 40 recently, because he is straining to reach the distance, which sacrifices his accuracy.
We had total control of the clock, the offence was rolling and the Bills had no answer for Kyren Williams, Puka, Higbee or anyone else. We should have gone forward for a TD.
McVay should have seen this, and he also should have observed from practice that Mevis cannot be counted to reliably hit anything beyond 40 yards. NFL kickers are generally so good now that anything up to 50 and even beyond are basically chip shots.
McVay should have had the offence go for a td, won the game and then replaced Mevis this week, as you can not reasonably have a kicker who you cannot count on to make the kicks that Mevis has been missing.
What is most alarming is the long-running ineptitude and glaring incompetence of our special teams units, our continuing inability to close out sacks, our poor tackling particularly in clutch situations , our failure to contain or restrict running QB's, and our inability to cover the short passing routes in the interior of our defence.
Of particular issue is that McVay clearly has not prioritized special teams, and it shows.
McVay's field goal decision just shouldn't have made given all of the known circumstances. It was stupid given the flow of the game and the known weaknesses of our kicker and special teams.
Another winnable game just got pissed away tonight