That's why I didn't put him in there. I'd give up my draft for Tebow.Username said:I'd trade it straight up for Tim Tebow
Now you're just being "ignorent."Username said:Say what ya want about them theres Tebow but that Bradford wheel never bes them quarterbacks that he is. He can throw the pigskin a quarter mile. Bradfords has the weakest arm in the NFls obviously.
Good point.JdashSTL said:Are we factoring in Bradfords injury concerns coming out? Im pretty sure Id give the edge to Luck because of that.
X said:Good point.JdashSTL said:Are we factoring in Bradfords injury concerns coming out? Im pretty sure Id give the edge to Luck because of that.
Well, since it's my alternate reality, let's say no. No injuries.
I'd have to say that would be a difficult decision. Both are cerebral, but I recently heard that Luck has an eidetic memory, and clearly he was (is) more of a physical specimen. Gil Brandt couldn't say enough about Bradford after his pro day though. I mean he absolutely raved.
Piggy-backing on your post (not addressing it), I think that whole "Passing League" stuff is beginning to phase out. There are a lot of good defenses out there now, including our own, who can put the kibosh on the passing game. Teams have figured out how to make Newton play to his weaknesses, and pretty soon they'll figure out how to make RGIII do the same. Stafford had 5000 yards last year and now he looks like he'll have significantly less.Faceplant said:Probably Luck. He is far more athletic than people give him credit for. He is also extremely bright and seems to have that ability to will his team. I was extremely impressed with that last drive on Sunday. Also, he is built like a tank, which should help him endure the rigors of the NFL better. He is one ugly mofo tho. Funny that everbody's darling of 2011 (Cam) is getting no love, haha.
I don't need thanks. We all do our part around here. But thanks for the thanks. :bg:Thordaddy said:Nice question .
If they'd all three been IN the same draft Luck probably would have been the highest rated so using ratings you'd be urged heavily to take him.
Me though ,I'm a bizz man and see the cap in every face ,I'd have tried to squeeze them and taken the one of the three I thought gave me the best cap value.
Micheal Jordon had to take a pay cut to get a team around him that could win, didn't Lebron do the same?
ALL AT THE SAME PRICE? Luck............... and JMO but three years into his career Luck will be further along than Sam is now no matter how many OC's he has,he played under center in college and knew how to do that from day one .
I think the multiple OC's is a sword that cuts two ways ,if your aim is a system QB it cuts this way,if you want a guy with vast perspective on the game and can be a coach on the field it cuts another.
But it's a great topic.
BTW did I thank you for this civily moderated forum lately?