Ranking our 2025 UFA Class

  • To unlock all of features of Rams On Demand please take a brief moment to register. Registering is not only quick and easy, it also allows you access to additional features such as live chat, private messaging, and a host of other apps exclusive to Rams On Demand.

AvengerRam

Benevolent Troublemaker
Joined
May 9, 2018
Messages
5,370
First, the good news.

The Rams upcoming UFA class does not have any “break the bank” or “make or break” impending free agents. That said, there are a few players who could be worth retaining.

Here is my priority list based upon the following factors: value, replaceability and anticipated cost.

1. Alaric Jackson (LT)
Jackson is a solid player. The Rams’ offense has definitely looked better since he returned from suspension in week 3. He also was a steady performer in 2023. But is he worth a long-term deal at LT, one of the higher paid positions? I’m on the fence on this one. My concern is that the market could overvalue him, as the LT UFA class (apart from the Ravens’ Ronnie Stanley) is pretty thin. On the other hand, early projections of the OT draft class are likewise not all that promising. This one will be a dilemma, and the Rams’ decision on his status could greatly impact their offseason plans.

2. Bobby Brown (DT)

I put Brown a hair behind Jackson at this point. He has been playing well, and he brings true NT size to the unit. I suspect he’ll be fairly affordable. If not, he certainly can be replaced with a mid-round pick. I’d like to see a 2-3 year deal (maybe 2 and an option) at a fair market price.

3. DeMarcus Robinson (WR)

Robinson fits the Rams scheme very well. While he clearly is not a No. 1 WR, when he’s able to draw single coverage, he can create mismatches, particularly in the Red Zone. His age (30) dictates that we’d be looking at a short term (1-2 years) deal. I think we could make that happen. Of course, if the Rams really like Jordan Whittington, maybe they save some money and let him walk.

4. Tutu Atwell (WR)

Atwell is younger than Robinson, and brings a unique speed factor to the WR corps. That said, his size limits his ability to take on that WR/TE-type role that the other Rams WRs. I’d say that the final 9 games of this season, perhaps more than any other member of the upcoming Rams UFA class, could result in a significant swing in either direction. And, of course, I don’t think we re-sign both Atwell and Robinson, so they almost need to be considered in tandem.

5. Jimmy Garoppolo (QB)

The fact that I’m even talking about a player who has not and, hopefully, will not play shows how shallow the UFA pool is. Still, the Rams will need to have a Stafford insurance policy in place for 2025 and (given that I’m on record as being someone with no faith in Stetson Bennett) Garoppolo is a solid No. 2.
Potential Bargain-Bin Keepers: Michael Hoecht, Larrell Murchison, John Johnson

Others (who I don’t really care if we retain): Joe Noteboom, Christian Rozeboom, Tyler Johnson, Troy Reeder, Hunter Long
 

jjab360

Legend
Joined
Jan 21, 2013
Messages
6,743
AJ has developed into the Havenstein of LTs. Steady enough to not get noticed which is a great thing to say about an offensive lineman, especially one playing the premium position.

Even though I wouldn't consider him a top talent, I'd like to have him back if the price is right. I don't really know how the rest of the league values somebody like him if he hits the open market though.
 

Classic Rams

Hall of Fame
Joined
Jan 15, 2016
Messages
3,341
Would like the Rams to sign AJ to a 3-4 year deal but there is the whiners' Trent Williams 3 year 82 mil contract (50 mil guaranteed) signed this year and I don't think the Rams would even pay half of that if they can get a cheaper quality LT.
 

Psycho_X

Legend
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
12,096
AJ has been an enigma for us... had his random IR stint couple years ago for the blood disease he had. And then this year his mysterious 2 game suspension that we don't know anything about. Since the Rams know what the 2 game suspension was for I'll trust them to know whether that's a red flag or not that should be considered. But he is obviously one of the most important players on our team currently considering how bad our offense was without him. He's a good, sometimes great, left tackle. It's hard to judge the worth of a player like that. A premium position that is hard to find.... he's in the drivers seat knowing we have no other option and other teams will throw bank at him. But we'll probably have to pony up just to make sure we have a LT next season.

BB3 is probably the only other player I'd make a push to get a multi year contract with but I wouldn't break the bank for him. Drob and Tutu I'd take back but we have options and the Rams can draft WRs well enough. I'd predict Drob back on another 1 year deal and Tutu will see whos willing to give him more playing time.
 

Jacobarch

Legend
Joined
Mar 28, 2016
Messages
5,310
Name
Jake
AJ is a must. He had a little bit of a rough game against Seattle, but I'm not sure if the protection calls were correct or if he was confused on who to block. Because on a number of plays he picked the wrong guy. However, he's been very solid for us when he plays. And a Solid LT is not easy to find. I also think he'll sign with the Rams for a decent price, he isn't going to break the bank. Obviously teams can overpay and some might, but usually the teams that overpay are bad ones. So we have that working for us as well. Get er done Snead.
 

WestCoastRam

Legend
Joined
Nov 17, 2014
Messages
6,241
Generally this team offers a competitive but not outlandish contract to good but not star players like AJ... except at LT last time with Noteboom. I'm not saying they should do it but I can see them overpaying a little for the LT spot.
 

Reddog99

Pro Bowler
Joined
May 21, 2019
Messages
1,349
As of now I'd like to see them keep Aleric Jackson and draft a LT if possible. Keep DRob for another year or two and let TuTu and Tyler Johnson go. Draft a receiver. Let Bobby Brown go. Draft a NT. Let Jimmy G go unless he will stay for cheap. If not pick up another cast off QB for cheap. Keep Hoecht and John Johnson and let the rest go.
 

DzRams

Starter
Joined
Mar 12, 2024
Messages
566
Name
Desmal M
Generally this team offers a competitive but not outlandish contract to good but not star players like AJ... except at LT last time with Noteboom. I'm not saying they should do it but I can see them overpaying a little for the LT spot.
I too see them trying to retain AJ as they did with Noteboom.

Except I don't think we can say they overpaid for Noteboom. He didn't get starting LT money.
 

WestCoastRam

Legend
Joined
Nov 17, 2014
Messages
6,241
I too see them trying to retain AJ as they did with Noteboom.

Except I don't think we can say they overpaid for Noteboom. He didn't get starting LT money.
ah okay, I didn't look at contract before posting. I think the assumption was that he was paid for more than what he showed in limited reps?? Felt like there was a strong reaction from NFL watchers on that contract.
 

DzRams

Starter
Joined
Mar 12, 2024
Messages
566
Name
Desmal M
First, the good news.

The Rams upcoming UFA class does not have any “break the bank” or “make or break” impending free agents. That said, there are a few players who could be worth retaining.

Here is my priority list based upon the following factors: value, replaceability and anticipated cost.

1. Alaric Jackson (LT)
Jackson is a solid player. The Rams’ offense has definitely looked better since he returned from suspension in week 3. He also was a steady performer in 2023. But is he worth a long-term deal at LT, one of the higher paid positions? I’m on the fence on this one. My concern is that the market could overvalue him, as the LT UFA class (apart from the Ravens’ Ronnie Stanley) is pretty thin. On the other hand, early projections of the OT draft class are likewise not all that promising. This one will be a dilemma, and the Rams’ decision on his status could greatly impact their offseason plans.

2. Bobby Brown (DT)
I put Brown a hair behind Jackson at this point. He has been playing well, and he brings true NT size to the unit. I suspect he’ll be fairly affordable. If not, he certainly can be replaced with a mid-round pick. I’d like to see a 2-3 year deal (maybe 2 and an option) at a fair market price.

3. DeMarcus Robinson (WR)
Robinson fits the Rams scheme very well. While he clearly is not a No. 1 WR, when he’s able to draw single coverage, he can create mismatches, particularly in the Red Zone. His age (30) dictates that we’d be looking at a short term (1-2 years) deal. I think we could make that happen. Of course, if the Rams really like Jordan Whittington, maybe they save some money and let him walk.

4. Tutu Atwell (WR)
Atwell is younger than Robinson, and brings a unique speed factor to the WR corps. That said, his size limits his ability to take on that WR/TE-type role that the other Rams WRs. I’d say that the final 9 games of this season, perhaps more than any other member of the upcoming Rams UFA class, could result in a significant swing in either direction. And, of course, I don’t think we re-sign both Atwell and Robinson, so they almost need to be considered in tandem.

5. Jimmy Garoppolo (QB)
The fact that I’m even talking about a player who has not and, hopefully, will not play shows how shallow the UFA pool is. Still, the Rams will need to have a Stafford insurance policy in place for 2025 and (given that I’m on record as being someone with no faith in Stetson Bennett) Garoppolo is a solid No. 2.
Potential Bargain-Bin Keepers: Michael Hoecht, Larrell Murchison, John Johnson

Others (who I don’t really care if we retain): Joe Noteboom, Christian Rozeboom, Tyler Johnson, Troy Reeder, Hunter Long
I wouldn't be shocked if they let every one of these UFAs walk, but I agree with your list as far as priority.

AJ - IMO, they'll try to sign him to a moderate extension prior to free agency ala Noteboom. If that doesn't happen, I believe they will sign a vet in free agency. I don't think the LT UFA class is as thin as you say. They have three solid options: Ronnie Stanley, Garrett Bolles, and Cam Robinson. That's more than most years.

Brown - They will let him walk. The Rams tend to broadcast their intentions in the previous year's draft by filling an upcoming hole the year before. Tyler Davis was drafted to be Brown's replacement.

DRob - I agree with everything you said about scheme fit but I suspect they'll be looking to make a big move at WR. They will have some money to spend and not many urgent free agents to retain as you noted. I think WR will be the position partially because they went hard after Mike Evans this last year. I could see them upgrading DRob with a Tee Higgins or Chris Godwin.

Atwell - He's gone. He's never fit or developed chemistry with Stafford. Also, see comment above on DRob.

Jimmy G - I have no feel for the backup QB position. I'm undecided on Bennett but think he can be in play. They'll also have other reclamation project QBs available. I do think it will be a vet versus a draft pick.
 

DzRams

Starter
Joined
Mar 12, 2024
Messages
566
Name
Desmal M
ah okay, I didn't look at contract before posting. I think the assumption was that he was paid for more than what he showed in limited reps?? Felt like there was a strong reaction from NFL watchers on that contract.
Agreed. It's fair to say he was paid more than what he showed in limited reps. IMO, they took a moderate risk in signing him. The plan was to get an LT starter at less than top LT starting money. If it works, you got a great deal; if it doesn't you're slightly overpaying for a highly versatile player who can spot start for you.
 

Psycho_X

Legend
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
12,096
Franchise tag Jackson. Don't pay him. Then draft LT.

The rest don't matter.
Yeah, actually like that idea. I usually would rather skip using the franchise tag at all costs but this is a case where it'd probably make sense. Can always trade him if a stud LT falls in our laps in the draft.
 

Allen2McVay

Legend
Joined
Mar 29, 2020
Messages
8,795
Name
Jim
Franchise Tag for Alaric Jackson?

Maybe ... but the OT tag cost $21M this year ... so figure it will $22M in 2025.

That's a lot. Could be half of the Rams' projected 2025 cap space.
 

dieterbrock

Rams On Demand Sponsor
Rams On Demand Sponsor
Joined
Jan 3, 2013
Messages
24,011
Franchise Tag for Alaric Jackson?

Maybe ... but the OT tag cost $21M this year ... so figure it will $22M in 2025.

That's a lot. Could be half of the Rams' projected 2025 cap space.
If they went this path I'd think they'd try to negotiate a longer term deal. He's a curious case alright.
On the other hand, has McVay ever even used the franchise tag?
 

Allen2McVay

Legend
Joined
Mar 29, 2020
Messages
8,795
Name
Jim
If they went this path I'd think they'd try to negotiate a longer term deal. He's a curious case alright.
On the other hand, has McVay ever even used the franchise tag?
I agree with regard to Alaric Jackson.

I believe the Rams used the Franchise Tag on Trumaine Johnson in 2017 ... McVay's first season ... but I don't know if the rookie Head Coach really made-the-call, or just agreed with the Front Office.

I also think a year (or two) later, they used the Transition Tag on LaMarcus Joyner but I am not sure.
 

CGI_Ram

Hamburger Connoisseur
Moderator
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
49,198
Name
Burger man
Franchise Tag for Alaric Jackson?

Maybe ... but the OT tag cost $21M this year ... so figure it will $22M in 2025.

That's a lot. Could be half of the Rams' projected 2025 cap space.
It’s a lot, but it minimizes the long term commitment and buys more time to figure the position out. We can always try to sign him later.
 

Allen2McVay

Legend
Joined
Mar 29, 2020
Messages
8,795
Name
Jim
It’s a lot, but it minimizes the long term commitment and buys more time to figure the position out. We can always try to sign him later.
Agree ... and I don't like the idea of building a roster by signing other teams' top free agents.
Augmenting the roster ... YES. Building it with key pieces ... NO.

I took a quick look at the current crop of 2025 free agents, focusing on Left Tackles, Cornerbacks and interior, run-stuffing D-Line (don't expect Bobby Brown to be re-signed). It's mostly an unimpressive list in my opinion, with a few good, veteran DL.

I consider those positions to be the Rams' primary 2025 Needs ... plus another WR.

Outside of Jedrick Wills, I don't see LTs that represent a clear improvement over Alaric Jackson; and I really don't see the Browns (even though they are cap strapped) letting Wills hit Free Agency.

So holding-on to Jackson and drafting a cornerback, might make sense. By-the-way, I also hate the idea of using a first round pick on a specific position. Far too restrictive.